~
- Standing on New Ground —
Standing on New Ground
Standing on New Ground
Women in Alberta
EDITED BY CATHERINE A. CAVANAUGH AND RANDI R. WARNE
ALBERTA NATURE AND CULTURE SERIES John E. Foster and Dick Harrison General Editors
THE UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA PRESS
The University of Alberta Press 141 Athabasca Hall Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2E8
Copyright © The University of Alberta Press 1993 ISBN 0-88864-258-X
Canadian Cataloguing in Publication Data
Main entry under title: Standing on New Ground: Women in Alberta
(Alberta nature and culture series) ISBN 0-88864-258-X
1 Women—Alberta. 2. Women—Alberta—History. I. Cavanaugh, Catherine Anne, 1945- II, Warne, RR (Randi Ruth), 1952- IIL Series. HQ1459.A4$83 1993 305.4'097123 C93-)91885-1
All nghts reserved
No part of this publication may be produced, stored ina retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without prior permission of the copyright owner.
Cover illustration
Annora Brown, Wild Sunflowers. Ol on canvas (Courtesy The University of Alberta Central Collection and used with permission of Morley Brown.)
Printed on acid-free paper. € Printed and bound in Canada by Quality Color Press Inc., Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Michael Owen
Catherine C. Cole Ann Milovic
Barbara Evans
Collette Lassiter Jill Oakes
Nanci Langford
Linda Trimble
Elaine H. Chalus
Margaret-Ann Armour
Pat Rasmussen
Patricia Roome
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements — vii Introduction ix
“Lighting the Pathways for New Canadians”: Methodist and United Church WMS Missions in Eastern Alberta, 1904-1940 1
Education, Community Service, and
Social Life: The Alberta Women’s Institutes and Rural Families, 1909-1945 19
“We Just Lived It As It Came Along”: Stories from Jessie’s Albums 33 Ranchwomen, Rodeo Queens, and Nightclub Cowgirls: The Evolution of Cowgirl
Dress 55
“All That Glitters”: The Political Apprenticeship of Alberta Women, 1916-1930 71
A Few Good Women: Female Legislators in Alberta, 1972-1991 87
From Friedan to Feminism: Gender and Change at the University of Alberta, 1960-1970 119
WISEST—An Initiative at the University of Alberta to Encourage Women into the Sciences and Engineering 145
Telling Our Story: Women’s Program and Resource Centre, 1981-1991 155 Remembering Together: Reclaiming Alberta Women’s Past 171
Alberta Nature and Culture Series offers informed commentary on Alberta and its people, past and present, and on related national and international issues. It brings together specialists from a range of disciplines in the Arts, Humanities, Social and Natural Sciences with writers and researchers from the wider community. The first title in the series is Buffalo.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
When we were invited by the General Editors of the Alberta Nature and Culture Series to put together a volume of collected works focussing on women in Alberta we readily agreed. The series’ man- date is to provide an interdisciplinary forum for works of general interest to a wide readership. This approach appealed to our own commitment to feminist activism and the subject of this special issue reflected our shared scholarly interest in prairie women. We also wel- comed the opportunity to continue our collaborative work which began in 1988 with an exhibition and video celebrating the sixtieth anniversary of the Persons Case and featuring the “Famous Five” Alberta women who successfully brought the action to the Privy Council in England in 1929.
We wish to thank our General Editors, John Foster and Dick Harri- son, for having had the idea in the first place and then generously sup- porting us at every stage of preparation and publication. Also a very special thank you to the women at The University of Alberta Press, especially Norma Gutteridge, Mary Mahoney-Robson, and Kerry Watt. Our editor, Barbara Demers, came highly recommended and then far exceeded her own reputation. Thank you Barbara for your profes- sional dedication and enthusiastic support.
vil
viii Acknowledgements
Our gratitude to the University of Alberta, the Historic Sites and Archives Services, Cultural Facilities and Historic Resources Branch, Alberta Community Development, and the Alberta Foundation for the Arts, a beneficiary of the Lottery Fund of the Government of Alberta, for their financial support.
We dedicate this volume to all Alberta women; past, present and
future. The Alberta HIRERTA Foundation ies for the Arts Sunisvon.onent
COMMITTED 10 THE DEVELOPMENT OF CULTURE AND THE ARTS
INTRODUCTION
Standing on New Ground: Women in Alberta continues a conversation about the place, history, and endeavours of women in Alberta. It is a prairie piece, acknowledging the impact of geography, settlement pat- terns, and aspirations for the future which continue to characterize the Canadian West. At the same time, it affirms Alberta’s uniqueness as a province with a distinctive political mix, economic base, and ide- ological diversity embodied in both its history and its contemporary realities. Standing on New Ground collects recent works of academic and independent researchers in an accessible and varied volume; its purpose will be achieved if readers become more aware of women’s experience in Alberta, and even more so if further discussion is sparked, and new voices join the conversation.
The papers in this volume range from explorations of the experi- ences of early women missionaries and settlers of European descent to contemporary efforts to shape Alberta’s social and cultural land- scape. A primary concern of the authors is the place Alberta women have occupied in and outside public institutions, both formal and informal. Within this broad framework important questions are raised about the perceived and actual role of women in the “public sphere” — a separate and primary domain occupied by men with authority over women’s “private sphere.” Alberta came into existence at a time when relations between women and men were widely defined by the
x Introduction
socially constructed concept of the companionate marriage, which assumed cooperation between women and men while each asserted authority over their separate and complementary spheres of influ- ence. Separate spheres technically granted women an equal share of power based on the division of authority by gender. In practice, how- ever, it was separate and hierarchical. The domestic sphere occupied by the woman/wife/mother was deemed important but subordinate to and supportive of the public sphere of the man/husband /father. While many women accepted these definitions of gender and their attending roles, others rebelled against them. Furthermore, gender roles were more permeable than separate spheres would suggest. The private and the public were often conflated as women actively made their own lives and communities through their day-to-day work, civic and political action, and community building.
Alberta women have a long history of activism. While our presence in the prairie west predates the establishment of the province of Alberta in 1905, the turn-of-the-century agrarian frontier provided Euro-Canadian women with a unique opportunity to intervene to redraw social divisions toward greater equality between men and women. References in the literature to women cutting their hair and donning “men’s” trousers upon their arrival in the West are sugges- tive of the transformative influence of the frontier.! More generally, the “pioneering partnership” between women and men forced by necessity to share the burdens of settlement in a harsh and often unforgiving environment gave support to women’s claim to full citi- zenship.?
Over time, the opportunity of the frontier, real or imagined, was muted, and divisions along gender lines were more sharply drawn. The resulting tensions between appearance and reality, image and experience which are explored here partly reflect the relative speed with which the Alberta frontier developed into a modern urban cul- ture which in itself generated new reforms. Thus, the twentieth cen- tury which began with the “woman question” is ending with a simi- lar though more wide ranging debate about women’s place within the institutional life of the province. During the early decades of the cen- tury, the total exclusion of women from public life encouraged a spe- cific focus on inclusion through the vote and other legislative reforms. Women have learned in the intervening years that other barriers exist to “personhood” such as the “glass ceiling,” the “double-day,” and the devaluation of women’s traditional experiences. In large part this discussion reflects the extent to which provincial women have
Introduction xi
rebelled against and continue to resist a restrictive ideal of their “proper place,” establishing new positions of authority for themselves and in the process reconstructing the prevailing views of womanhood and manhood. Alberta women have often been at the forefront of this change. For example, five women from Alberta, Emily Murphy, Louise McKinney, Henrietta Muir Edwards, Nellie McClung, and Irene Parlby, challenged the exclusion of women from the Senate and won constitutional recognition of women as “persons” in 1929. Nev- ertheless, the traditional assumption of a dependent, supporting, and subordinate womanhood persisted in Law long after the concept of partnership had redefined gender relations in public discourse. This disjunction was graphically illustrated in the 1970s when Iris Mur- doch, a southern Alberta farmwoman, failed in her divorce action to win a share in the family farm she had helped to build. When, in 1974, the court ruled against Murdoch because her labour was “just about what the ordinary rancher’s wife does” women across the country organized a successful campaign for legislation guaranteeing a wife's interest in family assets.* Under the new rules of law women moved from being viewed as matrimonial property to becoming equal own- ers in matrimonial property.
From midcentury significant social and economic changes together with women’s evolving activism have substantially broadened the context in which women’s struggle for equality has taken place. As the population of Alberta has become more culturally and ethnically diverse, new voices have brought a more varied perspective and a wider scope to women’s organized reform. Today, these struggles are as diverse as reproductive rights, band status for native women mar- ried to non-natives, and refugee status based on state-sponsored vio- lence against women. Resistance to sex discrimination continues in the context of shifting gender identities.
The works presented here capture some of the important develop- ments in the lives of Alberta women. In particular they show how women have attempted to influence, use, and transform formal and informal institutions or, alternatively, to create counter-institutions to more effectively meet women’s needs and advance their agendas. This exploration reveals much that is particular about women’s expe- rience in Alberta as well as suggesting ways in which it is continuous with other prairie cultures.
The prairie provinces hold a special place in Canadian culture as the site of intentional, structured “nation-building.” Vast expanses of land, a relatively open (though sex-specific) homesteading policy, and
xii Introduction
unabashed government propaganda drew settlers from both the Old World and the New. No less than Saskatchewan and Manitoba, Alberta saw enthusiastic efforts in this regard. Envoys from the domi- nant Anglo-Celtic culture took it upon themselves to “civilize” both the region’s original inhabitants and the many immigrant peoples who came west in the early years of this century to start a new life. In “Lighting the Pathways for New Canadians’: Methodist and United Church WMS Missions in Eastern Alberta, 1904-1940,” Michael Owen explores the particular efforts of the Woman’s Missionary Society of the Methodist Church to “Christianize” and “Canadianize” the Ukrainians of Alberta. There are at least two stories here to tell. Owen focusses on the so-called “civilizers” rather than on those who served as objects of their perhaps well-meaning but culturally imperialistic ministrations. His study illuminates the contradictions, both in action and in theory, experienced by WMS women in working toward the organization’s stated goals.
This exploration supports recent scholarship? which suggests that, in the end, the constructive achievements of providing educational and medical services were much more successful than missionary attempts at proselytism, either religious or cultural. Spurred on by assumptions of cultural superiority, missionaries provided needed and valuable social services to struggling immigrants facing immense hardships in a harsh and unfamiliar land. They were responsible for bringing medical services to outlying areas, and while their efforts to provide educational opportunities for young immigrants undoubt- edly reflected their concern to impart to “New Canadians” a particu- lar vision of Canadian life, they nevertheless offered the opportunity for education which could provide an entree into a better life. Nor were the Ukrainians who were the target of WMS efforts duped by their agenda. Ultimately, as Owen points out, the Woman's Mission- ary Society was forced to recognize that its overt assimilationist efforts among Ukrainians in western Canada were ineffective.
Owen's study reminds us of the complex nature of social change, and the often contradictory elements which inform its progress. It also encourages further study to elicit the voices of those who resisted efforts to shape them into an alien reality in order to hear their experi- ence and perceptions of their accommodation to their newly adopted land.
The task of “civilizing” the frontier was taken seriously by women of the dominant culture. During the early decades of this century women reformers increasingly worked through middle-class volun-
Introduction — xiii
tary clubs and organizations. The “club movement” was an attempt to respond more effectively to the scale of modern industrial life and its attendant social and economic change. This movement is usually seen as an urban phenomenon; however, in Catherine Cole and Ann Milovic’s study “Education, Community Service, and Social Life: The Alberta Women’s Institutes and Rural Families, 1909-1945,” we are reminded that rural Alberta provided fertile ground for women’s vol- untary associations as well. The success of the province’s women’s clubs owed much to the harsh conditions faced by many women liv- ing on isolated homesteads. Women’s Institutes along with other clubs and associations offered a means of overcoming the isolation of the prairie and building crucial social and political networks which often afforded women influence beyond what their numbers alone would allow. Indeed, by the 1920s Alberta women had gained a repu- tation as effective organizers. In a tribute to Alberta women, Mrs. McCorquodale, editor of the High River Times, said that she “would have no difficulty recognizing the Alberta women in Heaven. ... with pencils and notebooks, they would be in little groups beside the river of life putting the finishing touches to resolution B72894 urging that more rural children be taken into the Heavenly Choirs.”°
Established in Alberta in 1909 under the auspices of the provincial government, the nonsectarian, nonpartisan Alberta Women’s Insti- tutes (AWI) enjoyed an unrivaled popularity. Known as the rural women’s university, the AWI quickly established itself as the primary vehicle for the dissemination of information—touching on every aspect of rural women’s lives from child care to farm and home man- agement to legislative reform.®
Women’s clubs and organizations have been seen as important to the development of women’s networks and served as vehicles of entry into the mainstream of public life? By focussing on the relationship between the AW] and rural families, Cole and Milovic suggest a more complex relationship between women’s clubs and female solidarity. If, as the authors argue, family and club life were closely intermingled, then clubs would be less effective in providing an alternative for criti- cizing women’s traditional role within the family. In the case of the AWIs, however, the promotion and education of women as farm pro- ducers may have reinforced the notion of economic partnership.
Despite their apparent influence we know surprisingly little about the early history of women’s organizations. Did they, as Cole and Milovic suggest, play an important, formative role during the years of settlement and community building? In order to answer this question
xiv Introduction
we need to know much more about the membership as well as the specific programs and activities of various organizations. Who were its members, its leaders, and what was their underlying philosophy? Did they promote class, ethnic, and religious divisions, acting as lay missionaries preaching the gospel of the dominant Anglo middle- class, or did they appeal to a wide spectrum of society and therefore act as a mediating influence between social groups? What was the relationship between women’s social activities and women’s political activism? What strategies did they use to win community support?
Important clues about women’s lives are not only conveyed in the record of women’s organizations. Individual women too perceived and documented their frontier. One of these women was Jessie Burk Umscheid, who grew up on her family’s farm near present-day Milo. Umscheid’s vision of herself is the subject of Barbara Evans’s article, “We Just Lived It As It Came Along’: Stories From Jessie’s Albums.” Using photographs taken by Umscheid between 1917 and 1922, Evans explores several themes first raised in her film Jessie’s Albums. Jessie's pictorial history begins when she is fifteen years old and reflects her youthful optimism. Her intention is to capture the day-to-day life of women at work, at play, and in rare moments of solitary reflection. The result is a pictorial record that stands in marked contrast to the stiff, contrived photographs typical of professional photographers of the period. There is a compelling immediacy in Jessie’s images which seems to collapse time by drawing the viewer into the action.
As Evans points out, Jessie’s youthful vision challenges the view of pioneer farm women as socially isolated and burdened by the demands of family and hard physical labour under harsh frontier conditions. This study also raises questions about the construction of memory and the selection of perspective. By her own admission, Jessie intended to capture the positive moments of living life “as it came along.” There is no dark side to Jessie’s photographs, which end with the Depression because “{wle didn’t think it was anything too nice to take pictures of.” By editing out the negative images, Jessie constructed an uplifting vision of her life that sustained her through hard times. Evans reminds us of the subjectivity and purposefulness of memory and how it informs our understanding of the past. Her article also underscores the importance of who has control of the means of representing the past.
Lassiter and Oakes’s article, “Ranchwomen, Rodeo Queens, and Nightclub Cowgirls: The Evolution of Cowgirl Dress,” illustrates how powerful “official” images can be, creating the impression of a reality
Introduction — xv
which is in fact at significant variance with lived experience. “Cowgirl dress” has typically suggested a certain freedom and liberality of movement without challenging dominant conceptions of “feminin- ity.” As Lassiter and Oakes point out, this popular image has under- gone a number of changes throughout the years. Finding its origin in the garb of ranchwomen who came west to homestead in the mid- to late-nineteenth century, the popular form of cowgirl dress evolved in relation to a variety of cultural factors and emphases. Of particular significance was the popularity of Hollywood westerns in the 1940s and 1950s. Cowgirls kept the basic form of the practical attire worn by earlier generations of “rodeo girls” but embellished it through the use of seductive fabrics like satin and an overall concern for glamour and femininity reminiscent of Hollywood starlets. The emergence of the image of the “urban cowboy” brought another transformation in cow- girl dress, as designer blue jeans, fancy boots, and skin-tight shirts came into vogue.
According to Lassiter and Oakes, however, the popular image of cowgirl dress had little to do with the realities of women living the ranching life. Far from the sporty, romantic, or frankly sexual image portrayed through the stereotype, ranching women continued to adopt functional attire—sturdy “work pants, work shirts, and a well- worn Stetson.” Their historical overview gives rise to intriguing ques- tions about the relation between popular culture and practical reali- ties, and the power of that culture to make genuine innovations in dress (themselves reflective of certain social changes) conform to dominant notions of appropriate gender representation.
Nanci Langford’s article, “’All That Glitters’: The Political Appren- ticeship of Alberta Women, 1916-1930,” shifts our attention to the for- mal area of legislative politics. Here too the tensions between image, myth, and reality are brought to bear. As conventional wisdom would have it, women’s political activism culminated with the achievement of suffrage in 1916 only to disappear until the emergence of the women’s movement of the 1960s. Langford shows that in fact the postsuffrage years were important and productive both for the gains provincial women made and for the critical lessons they learned.
The period 1916-30 marks the entrance of women into the legisla- ture and cabinet and the achievement of much social legislation backed by the new woman voter. However, Langford notes that these victories were often far from complete. In contrast to the heady days of 1916, when Alberta women won the right to vote in provincial and municipal elections and on school matters, the 1920s saw the collapse
xvi Introduction
of the suffrage coalition and an increasingly conservative climate which eroded support for women’s reform agenda. In the face of growing divisions within their own ranks and renewed opposition from outside, reformers began to reassess the significance of equal voting rights as well as their organizational strategies for change.
Langford shows that the critical accomplishment of winning the vote was only the first step to women’s full and equal inclusion with men in the political life of Alberta. Thus, while 1916 marks the end of women’s formal exclusion from equal citizenship, the immediate postsuffrage period marks the beginning of the struggle to win full inclusion in the political process; as voters, members of political par- ties, legislators, and cabinet ministers. As provincial women took up that struggle they learned that the achievement of formal equality was insufficient in itself to achieve widespread social change. Indeed, having won the vote they found that they had lost a powerful strate- gic advantage. While lobbying and moral suasion were effectively applied by Alberta suffragists prior to achieving the vote, they carried less force once it could be said that women had the necessary tool to effect the changes to the social order that they advocated. Different strategies and stances would be required to achieve their goals in the postsuffrage world.
A more complete understanding of the lessons of women’s “politi- cal apprenticeship” could provide significant insights into the con- temporary struggle for political and social equality. Indeed, a central question for feminists today is whether women are most effective as agents of change working within or outside of existing structures and institutions.
In her study, “A Few Good Women: Female Legislators in Alberta, 1972-1991,” Linda Trimble asks the question: Do women make a dif- ference in political office? Using Alberta Hansard she examines the impact women have had on political discourse within the provincial legislature. At the heart of Trimble’s study is the question whether women’s issues can be effectively represented within existing political structures. The answer, of course, has important implications for how women organize for legislative change.
By tracking debates on so-called women’s issues over the past twenty years, Trimble identifies a number of encouraging trends. Despite significant barriers to women’s full participation in the legis- lature, she concludes that women—given sufficient numbers—can make a difference to both the tone and the substance of debate. How- ever, the difference that women make depends upon several critical
Introduction xvii
factors. First and foremost is the number of women elected as mem- bers of the Legislative Assembly. Trimble argues that a “critical mass” is necessary before women begin to have an influence on the kinds of issues brought before the legislature and the framework for the subse- quent debates. Second, she concludes that women make a difference when they are prepared to break the rules. Her study shows that as the number of women MLAs has increased they have been most effec- tive in representing women’s interests when they cooperate across party lines, work consensually, and pursue “issue-oriented discourse.”
According to Trimble, one of the most significant changes affecting the representation of women in the Alberta legislature is the increased presence of women within the ranks of the opposition. She points out that opposition women in particular have played a crucial role in advancing the debate on women’s reproductive, economic, and social choices. This study raises an intriguing question of what might be called the “feminization of opposition” in Canadian politics. Any con- clusion must await closer analysis of trends in other provincial legis- latures and the national parliament as well as comparative studies of nonparliamentary systems of government such as in the United States. If Trimble’s results can be applied to other jurisdictions then parliamentary structure may offer Canadian women an effective forum for change.
The political apprenticeship of some of the women currently hold- ing political office in Alberta began in the late 1960s and early 1970s at a time when the contemporary women’s movement erupted in a widespread critique of the narrow confines of women’s domestic role within the family. Initially, women struggled to establish an identity separate from the family and challenged the fantasy of “happiness ever after” that surrounded a domesticity which cast women as the emotional centre of the ideal household. As one early feminist wrote: “Our window on the world is looked through with our hands in the sink and we've begun to hate that sink and all it implies—so begins our consciousness.”8 What began as a rebellion against women’s con- finement within the family, “dusting her life away,” led to a wide- spread questioning of women’s role outside the home; in the paid labour force, in the professions, and in the boardrooms and the legis- latures of the nation.
The promise of women’s rebellion was liberation from the assump- tion of their domestic destiny to an assumption of freedom to choose their destiny. For many middle-class women in the 1960s the route to independence was through higher education. The Report of the Royal
xviii Introduction
Commission on the Status of Women in Canada, published in 1970, showed a dramatic rise in the number of women enrolled in Cana- dian universities beginning in 1960-61. The report noted that between 1955-56 and 1966-67 female participation rates had quadrupled while the male rate had doubled.? At the same time, the number of women enrolled in graduate programs was less than it had been four decades earlier in 1921.!0 In “From Friedan to Feminism: Gender and Change at the University of Alberta, 1960-1970,” Elaine Chalus examines the impact of these changes on undergraduates at the University of Alberta during the 1960s as revealed through the student newspaper, The Gateway, and the activities of the “Wauneitas,” an all-women’s club.
According to Chalus, during the early years of the decade, societal assumptions of women’s domestic destiny determined the acceptabil- ity and judgments about their right and ability to participate in post- secondary education. Women were not taken seriously as scholars. Their participation was largely limited to faculties such as Education and Household Science which reinforced notions of women’s domes- tic function. While undergraduate men were expected to prepare for future careers in the professions it was widely assumed that under- graduate women would equip themselves to be better wives and mothers. Indeed, it was commonly believed that the primary objective of most “freshettes” was a “MRS” not a BA or MA. By the midsixties women were beginning to challenge these social conventions by demanding greater personal freedom and an end to sex segregation. Chalus finds that change for University of Alberta women was grad- ual but significant throughout the 1960s. The debate, which ranged from “free love” to child care to combining career and family, was full of contradictions and, not surprisingly, gave rise to tensions that sometimes erupted in open hostility toward women, particularly fem- inist women,
Chalus makes a convincing case for the need to return to the ori- gins of the contemporary women’s movement, both within universi- ties and outside them, in order to assess its meaning in our lives today. In particular, her study raises questions about the influence of the 1960s generation of women in shaping feminism during the sub- sequent decades and how feminism made a difference in their own lives and the lives of their daughters.
One of the features of current feminism is a commitment to broad- ening horizons and the range of choices available to girls and women as they shape their own lives. If institutional structures have proved a
Introduction — xix
barrier, education has been seen as a means of gaining entry to and transforming those structures. Women educators have undertaken a special responsibility to make educational institutions accountable to their own ideal of open access. As Chalus shows, however, access alone is insufficient; advocacy is often necessary.
At the University of Alberta direct action was taken to advocate women’s entry into the scientific professions. Through an initiative taken by the late Dr. J. Gordin Kaplan, WISEST (Women in Scholar- ship, Engineering, Science and Technology) was established in 1982. Its mandate was to “increase the percentage of women in decision- making roles in all fields of scholarship.”
Margaret-Ann Armour offers a description of WISEST and the var- ious programs it has sponsored to encourage female participation in the fields of science, technology, and engineering. One such program provides girls and women with “hands on” experience of what scien- tists or engineers do in their daily work, familiarizing them with what might otherwise seem an alien discipline. Other initiatives include an annual conference at which high school and university women have the opportunity to meet with women in nontraditional careers and ask them questions about their work. They also learn about how these women manage competing demands of family and personal life, given current societal expectations. Overall, WISEST initiatives are successfully reaching an increasing number of girls and women, building toward the association’s goal of bringing female perspectives and agendas into science’s historically male preserve.
This collection illustrates that existing structures are not always sufficient to address issues which women would want to bring to the fore. New organizations are required. One of these, as we have seen, is WISEST; another is the Women’s Program and Resource Centre established on the University of Alberta campus as a subunit of the Faculty of Extension in 1981.
Pat Rasmussen, a former director of the Women’s Program, “tells the story” of its inception, development, and intended goals over a ten year period. She documents the framing of the program’s man- date to include a strong community development perspective and social change agenda, and the modification of some of its specific goals and practices over time. Despite constraints facing the program, many important resources have been made available to women. Espe- cially useful has been the establishment of a data base system funded by the Secretary of State in 1986-87. “Womansource” lists the pro- gram’s myriad books, offprints, bibliographies, and binder materials,
xXx Introduction
allowing users to access essential but otherwise difficult-to-obtain materials on women.
Rasmussen’s study illuminates the considerable practical difficul- ties, such as the reality of project-by-project funding, which have served equally with a prejudicial environment outside the program to make its successful operation such a challenge. “Telling Our Story” raises important questions about the relation of physical space/loca- tion and an institution’s philosophy, the relationship and positioning of women’s groups vis a vis one another, and the tradeoffs involved in being an “alternative” institution within a larger system. Too, it highlights the tensions between some feminist objectives and the abil- ity of existing institutions to embody radical change. Can effective social change be brought about within established institutions? If so, what are the costs?
We conclude this volume with Patricia Roome’s “Remembering Together: Reclaiming Alberta Women’s Past.” As the range of contri- butions above indicate, women in Alberta have engaged numerous structures, formal and informal, in their struggle for identity and equality. However, this collection tells but one small part of the story. There is a much larger tapestry within which these explorations figure. The voices which are missing from this essentially white, northern Euro-American Protestant conversation are lifted up in “Remembering Together.” Roome provides an accessible yet detailed literature review which illustrates the breadth of the subject matter and the amount of work which remains to be done. In mapping this territory, Roome notes differences in interpretation, developments in perspective, and representative scholars in the field. In particular, we are called to attend to the missing voices of native, Metis, and Ukrainian women. Recent literature dealing with these excluded women raises important questions about the power dynamics which gave rise to their exclu- sion. Roome also points out that even a woman of relative ethnic, class, and urban privilege “could not speak loud enough to be heard by future generations.” Elsie Park Gowan is an Alberta playwright whose works have only now been rediscovered. “Remembering Together” underscores the essential task of continuing to retrieve the lives of all Alberta women. As the various pieces in this volume illus- trate, we need to be continually aware of the contexts of women’s lives and the opportunities and barriers they experienced as a result.
The studies here show that even in the land of fresh beginnings the ground was not neutral ground. Inherited prejudice and power shaped the cultural agenda. The dominant culture continued to
Introduction — xxi
reshape the new vision according to its own mythology. Yet the West did create spaces for women to see themselves in new ways. Through political activism Alberta women have intervened to claim existing cultural structures as rightfully their own. They have strug- gled to shape their own ground through access to institutions in order to change them. Yet, thus far, it could be argued, the best that has been achieved is access. The ground is never simply won. Today women find themselves fighting many of the same battles their fore- mothers did.
One strategy from the past which women are reclaiming is advo- cacy through woman-specific groups and organizations. While inte- gration on the same basis as men is essential, the lack of neutral ground requires a safe and specific place from which women can act. This collection identifies some of those places; others remain to be explored.
Standing On New Ground provides a critical perspective from which to consider women’s experience in and of Alberta. It invites further exploration, and the charting of new and fresh directions from the vantage point of women’s history, experience, and aspirations.
Catherine A. Cavanaugh is completing a Ph.D. dissertation on Irene Parlby, an Alberta pioneer, founding member and president of the United Farm Women of Alberta, and Minister Without Portfolio in the United Farmer’s government from 1921 to 1935. Cathy’s recent article “The Limitations of the ‘Pioneering Partnership’: The Alberta campaign for ‘Homestead’ Dower 1909-1925” appears in Canadian Historical Review 124, no 2 (June 1993). She 1s a tutor at Athabasca University, an Alberta-based distance, open university with students across Canada
Randi R Warne completed her PhD in Religion and Culture at the University of Toronto in 1988. Her dissertation, entitled “Literature As Pulpit,” an analysis of the reli- gion, feminism, and social activism of Nellie L. McClung, will be published by Wilfrid Laurer University Press this year In addition to several articles on McClung and on religious social activism in Canada, she has published in the area of feminist methodol- ogy. Rand: has taught religion and culture, social ethics, and women and religion in several contexts, including the University of Lethbridge and the University of Alberta Most recently, she has been program director at St. Stephen’s College at the University of Alberta. She 1s currently president of the Canadian Society of Church History As an actor, Randi performs dramatic monologues in the character of Nelhe McClung across the country.
Notes J One example 1s Helen Shaw who cut off her “lovely golden hair” shortly after arriving in the Northwest in 1883. See Emma Curtin, “Two British Gentlewomen,” Alberta History (Autumn 1990), p 12 When Mollie Dorsey Stanford arrived in the Colorado Territones in the 1860s she borrowed a riding habit and went riding across the plains Pronouncing it a “delicious sport,” she wrote, “I felt like a bird uncaged.” Quoted in Carl N. Degler, At Odds: Women and the Family in America (New York Oxford University Press, 1980), p. 46. Susan Jackel, ed., A Flannel Shirt
xxii
10.
Introduction
and Liberty (Vancouver: The University of British Columbia, 1982) concludes that the psychological impact of the unoccupied space of the frontier was experienced as liberating by British emigrant gentlewomen in the Canadian West. Eliane Leslau Silverman, “Women’s Perceptions of Marriage on the Alberta Frontier,” Building Beyond The Homestead, David C. Jones and lan MacPherson, ed (Calgary: The Uni- versity of Calgary Press, 1985), pp. 49-64, reminds us of the limitations of this inter- pretation which probably applies to British middle class women in particular.
. Prairie reformers frequently based their claim to rights for women on the “pioneer-
ing partnership” and it is worth noting that when he introduced the new suffrage bill in 1916 Premier Sifton declared that by their heroic pioneering work provincial women had earned “an unalterable mght by eternal justice to be placed on an equality with men.” Quoted in Catherine Lyle Cleverdon, The Woman Suffrage Movement m Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1950), p. 73.
Reports of Family Law 13 (Toronto: Carswell, 1974), pp. 185-209.
. See for example, Ruth Compton Brouwer, New Women of God: Canadian Presbyterian
Women and India Missions, 1876-1914 (Toronto. University of Toronto Press, 1990), and Leshe A. Flemming, ed., Women's Work for Women. Misstonartes and Soctal Change in Asia (Boulder: Westview Press, 1989).
. Nellie McClung, The Stream Runs Fast (Toronto: T Allen, 1945), p. 185. . Shelly Anne Marie Bosetti, “The Rural Women’s University: Women’s Institutes in
Alberta 1909-1940” (M.Ed. thesis, University of Alberta, 1983) examines the educa- tional role of the AWI.
. Karen J. Blair, The Club Woman As Feminist. True Womanhood Redefined, 1868-1914
(New York: Holmes & Meier, 1980)
. Sheila Rowbotham, The Past Is Before Us: Feminism in Action Since The 1960s (Lon-
don. Penguin, 1990), p. 1.
. Report of the Royal Commission on the Status of Women in Canada (Ottawa. Informa-
tion Canada, 1970), p. 169. Ibid.
MICHAEL OWEN
“Lighting the Pathways for New Canadians”
Methodist and United Church WMS Missions in Eastern Alberta, 1904-1940
“{Olur work among the Austrian people . .. [is] to make them Christ- ian and Canadian. ...[A] good Canadian is a Christian,” stated Edith Weekes Leonard in The Austrian People, published by the Woman’s Missionary Society of the Methodist Church. Leonard, a missionary at Wahstao and Kolokreeka, small settlements near Smoky Lake, Alberta, between 1905 and 1910, believed wholeheartedly in the goal of the Methodist missions among the Ukrainian people settled in Alberta to create “good Canadians.” “Here,” she continued, “is the sufficient and complete justification for our whole work, comprising day school, night school, Sunday school, sewing-meetings, evangelistic visiting, caring for children in the mission homes, visiting the sick and helping those who need help in business transactions. In a word, here is the justification for our life among the Austrian people.”!
Leonard revealed much about the work and the motivations of the women who devoted their lives to the Alberta missions of the Methodist (later United) Church’s Woman’s Missionary Society. Leonard’s description of the work among Ukrainian immigrants shows us these paragons of Christian Canadianism at their best and worst. Leonard’s ignorance of the national origins of many of the new immigrants, lumping Austrians, Russians, Ukrainians, and Poles into one great national conglomeration, was shared by most Canadians of the era. She adhered to the view of middle-class Protestant Canadians
1
2 Michael Owen
that there was one manifestation of Canadian nationality: that of the dominant evangelical Protestants of Anglo-Celtic heritage. Leonard’s description of Methodist missions among the “Austrians” illustrated well the multitude of activities through which she and her compan- ions attempted to bring New Canadians their understanding of Cana- dian nationalism and Protestant Christianity. By the 1930s, the emphasis had shifted, but only slightly. In its 1934 report, the board of Home Missions informed United Church members that “the mission- ary enterprise is an endeavour of idealists to produce through the reli- gion of Jesus Christ a Canadian Christian citizenship out of the many varied and mutually contributing cultures.” While paying lip-service to Canada’s multicultural society, the board argued that “in immi- grant areas of the Western plains,” missionaries still worked to over- come “issues created by mistaken Government policies in establishing colonies and endeavoured to create on the part of the people an atti- tude of receptivity to the Gospel of Jesus Christ as we understand it.”?
Although they agreed with these views, WMS missionaries were generally more positive toward the New Canadians and their contri- bution to Canadian life. While providing a range of religious and social services to New Canadians, these women came to an awareness and an understanding, albeit limited, of the value of the New Cana- dian to Canada. While subscribing to prevalent opinions of the non- Anglo-Celtic immigrants as irreligious, corrupted, and corruptible, intemperate and unhygienic, they also argued against these notions and claimed instead that the New Canadians were deeply religious and committed to their new nation. In this paper, I explore the often conflicting opinions, attitudes, and motivations of these women mis- sionaries among the Ukrainian settlers of northeastern Alberta. I note their insensitivity to the religious and cultural traditions of the New Canadians and acknowledge their unstinting attachment to their church and its self-imposed mission to protect Canada from all that it perceived as non-British and non-Christian. Nevertheless, these women were often motivated by kindness and empathy for the plight in which many New Canadians found themselves. Through this study, I hope to recover some Alberta women’s experience in the first decade of the twentieth century.3
Background to Missions in Alberta
In the period 1890 to 1930, Canadians viewed non-Anglo-Celtic immi- grants with a mixture of foreboding and pride. The Anglo-Celtic
“Lighting the Pathways” 3
majority, Protestants and Catholics alike, believed immigration was the only way in which the prairies could be populated and Canada could assume its rightful place as the leader of the British Empire.4 Yet their vision of Canada was threatened by European immigrants who settled in cities, in resource towns of western Canada, and “en bloc” in Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta.° In a 1925 pamphlet printed in honour of the Methodist Woman’s Missionary Society’s work, Mrs. W.H. Graham captured the view of the majority middle- class Canadians toward non-British immigrants and the churches’ task in protecting the nation while uplifting these New Canadians:
These European folk[s] who have come in response to a hearty invitation constitute a problem all their own....[TJhey settle in drifts on our wide provinces, and in the downtown areas of our cities. . .. [Their] mass ideals are not high, customs are crude, super- stition is rife. Canadian liberty is not sufficient to lift them from these lower levels. It must be imbued with something higher. Only Christ can make Christians, only a knowledge of the ideals of Jesus can give true freedom.... Unfortunately these new-comers from Central Europe have been allowed to segregate themselves in solid communities, where they maintain their old-world customs, and fail to come in touch with Canadian ideals and ways of living. . . .6
New Canadians appeared impervious to the efforts to build a nation in the West—a nation that would be imbued by evangelical Protestant principles and a commitment to a British heritage.
To overcome this apparent threat to Canada’s destiny, mainline Protestant denominations initiated evangelical, educational, and med- ical missions among New Canadians. Although New Canadians, or “foreigners” as they were commonly called, belonged to Christian churches, few Protestant denominations accepted their traditions as legitimate expressions of Christian faith. Among church societies that developed and financed missions to New Canadians was the Methodist Woman’s Missionary Society (WMS). Its missions to Ukrainians of Alberta had three purposes: to bring to the immigrants a “true” understanding of the saving gospel of Jesus Christ as one’s personal saviour and as interpreted by these Protestant denomina- tions; to bring to the immigrants educational, medical, and social ser- vices that were otherwise unavailable in remote locations; and to save Canada for Christ by converting new European immigrants to the twin gospels of evangelical (Protestant) Christianity and Canadian nationalism.
4 Michael Owen
Wahstao, Kolokreeka, and Edmonton-——Centres of Christianity and Canadian Nationalism
Dedicated to saving Canada and Ukrainian settlers for Christ, Methodist women missionaries served as evangelists, teachers, nurses, doctors, and social workers because of their abiding faith in Christianity as an evangelical religion. As staunch Canadian national- ists, these women believed in a Canadian morality and Canadian character defined within the frame of liberal Protestant Christianity. In their service to the immigrants, Methodist (and United) Church women missionaries brought to their work the belief that they served both God and the nation by teaching the New Canadians about Jesus Christ as a personal saviour, the errors of non-Protestant churches, and the need to subscribe to the principles of personal hygiene, tem- perance, political purity, and Sabbath observance. Apparently, few understood that many immigrants subscribed to similar principles, although with different interpretations of what was and was not pos- sible in their new environment.
The Woman's Missionary Society opened its first mission to Alberta’s Ukrainian immigrants in 1904 when Reta Edmonds and Jessie Munro undertook a long and arduous journey to Wahstao (near present-day Smoky Lake) over a trail filled with stumps, ruts, sloughs, and swarms of mosquitoes. In the next twenty years, WMS missions expanded to Kolokreeka, Smoky Lake, Pakan, Lamont, Chipman, Radway, Bonnyville, and Edmonton. These women mis- sionaries to the Ukrainian communities in the Smoky Lake-Lamont- Pakan region—teachers, nurses, evangelists—believed completely in the task that the society had set for them.” From their perspective, they “grasped the torch of enlightenment and held it high. ... They lived among the settlers, learned their language, shared their hospital- ity, won their confidence, allayed their suspicions, and interpreted Christian Canada.” They believed that they “exemplified the best of Canada, and..., with God’s help, they could build a Canada in which He would have dominion, and the day would dawn when those immigrants would no longer be ‘strangers and foreigners’ but good fellow-Canadians.”8
To achieve these goals of Canadianizing and “Christianizing” Ukrainian immigrants, Methodist women missionaries employed a variety of strategies: Sunday schools, home visits, evening schools for adults and young people for instruction in English, and “private” schools, when public schools in the district were few and open only irregularly. Sunday schools were a prominent aspect of Protestant
“Lighting the Pathways” 5
churches’ religious education for children and youth. Respecting this tradition, Edmonds and Munro, for example, had gathered three boys and one girl into a Sunday school in their tent even as their mission buildings were under construction. They also held itinerant Sabbath schools and services in the homes of settlers whenever possible. Although attendance at home-based Sunday schools fluctuated greatly, with just one or two families present, the women missionaries were “very hopeful of good” from this work. Distributing New Testa- ments and tracts to the boys and girls, they revelled in the achieve- ments of the older children who earned Bibles “by memorizing verses” while younger children received “a copy of Matthew as soon as they can read even a very little.” They judged Ukrainian children’s Bible reading “very favourably with that of Canadian children of the same school standard.”? While they emphasized English-language instruction, often telling Bible stories “for the whole school in English before the classes begin,”! some employed the language of the peo- ple to teach gospel lessons. At Kolokreeka, where a Sunday school was opened in 1909, the missionaries conducted the Bible teaching “almost entirely ...in Russian” supplemented by “a little English . . . each day, so that in five Sundays they have learned nearly thirty words.”!! These English language stories had a threefold purpose: improving English skills of the children, transmitting to the children the teachings of the church, and, covertly, transmitting to the home an understanding of both Canadian morality and Protestant evangelism.
While Sunday schools occasionally became the nuclei of separate congregations,!2 thereby providing women missionaries with a sense of accomplishment, more often they became lightning-rods of denom- inational and ethnic conflict. When local priests objected to Ukrainian settlers sending their children to the Methodist Sunday schools, atten- dance dropped off quickly. In 1909, Ethelwyn Chace reported on the “checkered career” of the Bavilla Sunday School. Closed for one month “in the depth of the winter,” attendance varied from twenty- five to one. “This last was on a day immediately following a visit of the Greek Orthodox priest to the church four miles distant. This co- incidence,” Chace argued, “is suggestive. The following Thursday, at our annual picnic, that school was represented by a full score, every [sic] smallest child of whom walked four miles each way.” Priestly intervention, real or fancied, was anticipated by the missionaries. Edith Weekes, then at the Kolokreeka, reported on the success of one Sunday school until mid-March 1909, “when just one boy came, instead of fifteen, because of the mandate of the priest.” Children returned gradually until July when another decline occurred, “fol-
6 Michael Owen
lowed by a complete cessation. ...” Three years later, there was “no regular Sunday School at [Kolokreeka], because of the direct opposi- tion of the Greek Catholic priest,” claimed Phoebe Code. She kept the mission house open for nearby settlers who joined the missionaries “in singing, Bible study and conversation, as opportunity affords.” 13 In spite of the opposition, these women persevered. Sunday schools remained open, even for one or two faithful followers. The missionar- ies attributed more to the priest’s intervention than to the settlers’ own preference for familiar and traditional forms of worship and social intercourse. Optimistically underestimating the influence of the priest who “had not made any serious difference in our work,” except that the people attended the “Ukrainian” church more often on Sun- days and church holidays, Ella MacLean stated that missionaries did not encroach “on priestly territory, for the priest does not visit the homes.”!4 Weekes felt “no difference in the attitude of the people toward us; they are as friendly as before, and we believe it is only the rush of work that shuts us from their homes.” However, homes were shut to Methodist women because of the priests’ opposition. They “rejoiced” at the opposition. Alice Stanford believed that “the greatest darkness is before the dawn” and was not discouraged.!> Chace took it “as a tribute to our influence and as a more hopeful sign than pas- sive indifference.” 16
Yet not all the opposition to the Methodist women’s work came from the priests. Opposition, however muted and not obvious to the missionaries, came from the people themselves and, in the 1920s and 1930s, from indigenous communist and Ukrainian national move- ments.!7 WMS women, ironically, did not recognize the importance of religion as a component of Ukrainian nationalist sentiment. But oppo- sition of the nationalist movement, Margaret Addison claimed, forced the WMS “to rethink our missionary work.” They challenged “our every motive and our work, it is they who say that we are no longer needed. Are we ready to step out?” Ukrainian Canadians questioned the missionaries’ “right to claim that our church offers more opportu- nity for Christian living than does theirs.”'® The results of any self- inquiry by the women missionaries were not detailed in their reports.
Religious enthusiasm permeated all WMS missionaries’ contacts. Sunday schools and church services were clearly evangelical. Social activities and community work also had evangelical overtones. Alice Stanford romantically described the weekly “sewing meeting” held at Wahstao in 1911-12. “Such chattering, laughing, and hushing of babies! The work-hardened fingers could only hold the largest of needles, but
“Lighting the Pathways” 7
the women were quite willing to sew the stiffest of squares, if only they were bright and pretty.” The conversation at sewing meetings held in the mission house or homes of the women, with missionaries bringing quilting squares and supplies, always turned to the gospel. Apparently Ukrainian women “eagerly” listened “to the simple gospel story” and sang hymns, demonstrating that “evidences of real heart interest were never wholly wanting... .”!9 Men also showed “genuine interest” by asking “many very earnest questions. . .”29 Although WMS missionaries used these meetings for evangelism, Ukrainian women used them for the equally important reason of social meeting. The men may have been present to oversee the women and their relations with the Methodist interlopers.
The most promising institutions, in the missionaries’ view, were the school homes. WMS missionaries believed unfalteringly in the power of the public school to Canadianize the New Canadians.?! Reflecting on opposition encountered to their evangelism, Chace emphasized “the strategic importance of the Public School. If the worst should come ... that homes should be shut against us, that our Bible talks should be hindered, that our Sunday schools should be depleted ...the Public School is, humanly speaking, the surest weapon that can be used against ignorance and bigotry.”22 Evangelis- tic meetings and night schools for adults had some efficacy, but to WMS missionaries the future lay in educating the children, “captur- ing” them for Christ and Canada, and training them to be the leaders of the future. Through children the “influence of Canadian ways and Christian teaching” would permeate the home, the children providing the link between parents and teachers. E.J. Kerr, associate field secre- tary of the WMS, viewed Ukrainian work in Alberta as most promis- ing since the opening of a government school at Wahstao in 1907. Under the direction of a teacher, also a WMS missionary, children made “rapid progress, many of them reading the English Bible flu- ently and intelligently.” However, the public school system, effec- tively controlled by provincial authorities, did not spread widely throughout eastern Alberta until the 1920s and 1930s. Moreover, when available, public schools were open only sporadically. There- fore, while Methodist missionaries supported the public school sys- tem, they formed private schools to meet an apparent demand for education from settlers and because children made better progress in acquiring the English language and other skills necessary for integra- tion into Canadian society if their attendance was more regular. Before government day schools opened in the Wahstao district in 1907,
8 Michael Owen
the WMS had operated a school for the children of the district.2? Kerr reported that “teaching of the public school from May to November [and] a private school in the Home during the winter” comprised a major activity of the women missionaries.24 These private schools provided children with educational benefits and, from the missionar- ies’ perspective, superior care in a “Christian” home environment. Missionaries praised Ukrainian children’s ability to learn and parents who took advantage of opportunities for children to attend school regularly. To Dell Young, teacher at Wahstao in 1911-12, “the work is most encouraging, as the children make good progress, in spite of the difficulty of learning a new language. It surprises one to see how quickly even the little ones pick up English. Of course we allow only English spoken in the school. The children are almost invariably quick to learn, their desire to learn accounting for their rapid progress.”?° Such progress, again from the missionaries’ perspective, demon- strated the efficacy of these services in promoting the assimilation of the Ukrainian Canadians.
The Wahstao “School Home” was representative of Protestant edu- cational facilities for Ukrainian children. In the Wahstao district, pub- lic schools were built at Bavilla and Provischena in 1906, but opened only during the summer. Mission workers firmly believed that Ukrainian children would be served better if schools were open for longer periods, especially in the winter. The school homes, missionar- ies believed, met these educational and spiritual needs of the children.
There are fifteen or more children who would come to us for the winter if we had the accommodation. Four will be the most we can possibly take, unless we extend our building. We need a school room and children’s dining room on the ground floor and bed- rooms upstairs. Although Public Schools will soon be built, these are but for the summer months; and cannot in any case take the place of a boarding school. The school might not be entirely self- supporting for a time, for cash with our people is scarce, but there are other ways in which they could help, and as they came to know more of the benefits of such a school, we feel confident each would try to contribute his share. This work was not planned for in the beginning but it seems to have opened up before us, and now that we have a small Christian community to draw from, we are not so much afraid of the priest spoiling the plan.26
By the 1920s the Wahstao School Home had an enrolment of thirty students, with a staff of four.
“Lighting the Pathways” 9
The Wahstao “School Home,” and school homes at Kolokreeka and Radway, served both as residences for students and as “schools.” The curriculum at all Methodist and United Church-operated mission schools followed the prescribed Alberta Department of Education guidelines, suitably modified to meet the needs of children and the goals of the mission. In 1918 Miss Robinson, a native Albertan who had been trained at the WMS Training School in Toronto, asserted that students in the boarding home received “instruction along the lines provided by our public school curriculum|,] ... lessons in domestic science—laundry, etc.—and most important of all lessons in the life of Christ.”27
But the school home, stressed Alice Stanford, teacher at Wahstao in 1912, gave missionaries advantages for nation-building and conver- sion that were not available in the public school. The school home gave the missionaries unrestricted access to and control over the chil- dren. This influence was essential since WMS missionaries “firmly believeld] that much of the hope of this work lies in the children whom we have come in closest contact with in the home, and that the sooner provision is made for keeping more children constantly in the house, the better for them and for all the future of this neighbour- hood.”28 To Dell Young, the school home was primarily a religious initiative: “Two of the children staying with us have already given themselves to Christ, and only those living with them can realize how much this means. Two little girls, who left us last spring ..., were influenced and greatly interested.” At Kolokreeka, where seven chil- dren sojourned for different periods of time during the same year, the home is “not only a school for English education but a place where the spirit of Jesus Christ ... makefs] itself felt in the lives of the chil- dren.”29 In the school homes, missionary-teachers rarely missed opportunities to further religious as well as nation-building goals. Religious holidays were celebrated by concerts. Local clergy, espe- cially Protestant Ukrainian ministers such as Mr. T. Hannochko, assisted the WMS workers and provided services to the mission every Sunday evening. Such services, especially when provided in Ukrain- ian by a Ukrainian convert to Methodism, greatly enhanced the effi- cacy of the mission and its religious and nationalistic goals.
Sunday schools, where the missionary held sway, often created a demand for school homes. For example, in 1905, one year after the opening of Wahstao, Edith Weekes began Sunday schools between Smoky Lake and Pakan in settlers’ homes. Soon, according to the mis- sionaries, a demand developed for a “Home and School.” A site was located north of Smoky Lake at Kolokreeka. Ella MacLean and Edith
10 Michael Owen
Weekes superintended the construction of a new building and opened this mission on 31 December 1909. Kolokreeka was not a pretentious building, having a basement, a kitchen, a dining-sitting room, pantry, three small bedrooms, and two dormitories with room for eight chil- dren in each. Like Wahstao, Kolokreeka had Sunday schools, Sunday services, and evening English classes for adults. Missionaries held Sab- bath schools and services in points outside Kolokreeka. Kolokreeka, however, was primarily a “school home,” that is, the mission was a private school for children from families outside the settlement who wished their children to obtain an education but did not wish to send them to Edmonton. Mission staff, some of whom were trained teach- ers, served as teachers in the school, and used the prescribed Alberta curriculum, and “Christian” reading materials—the Bible and Methodist magazines. By 1914, Kolokreeka had some thirty-one boarders in its dormitories with thirty more students in the day school. Fifteen years later, attendance remained stable at twenty-four pupil-boarders, most under the age of twelve years. Mission staff taught all classes to the eighth grade while older children attended the high school at Smoky Lake. Visitors, including parents, were care- fully supervised. Parents were provided “Christian” tracts to take away. Reading materials supplied to the children were similarly scru- tinized for “only such papers ...as have real value in provision of good, wholesome things with a Christian point of view.”*" How these reading materials were put to use is not discussed.
As more efficient transportation linkages and public and Ukrainian parochial schools extended their reach to rural Alberta communities in the 1920s and 1930s, the WMS gradually shifted the emphasis of Kolokreeka from a school home to a “Community Centre” with Sun- day schools, midweek groups including Canadian Girls in Training (CGIT) and Tuxis, a kindergarten, sewing classes for young and older women, summer camps for children, and recreation. By the mid- 1930s, Mary Mansfield could report that Kolokreeka school had ful- filled “its first great need and outlived its usefulness as a school home and a change of policy is now expected.” Girls’ clubs continued to teach traditional skills that “help in home making—fancy work, sewing, knitting, cooking” but the mission, as with other United Church congregations, was unable to find suitable male leaders “to work with the boys and young men.”3! Kolokreeka merged with the Smoky Lake mission and women missionaries became community workers. Throughout its life, Kolokreeka staff watched over the lives of its charges, attempting to influence children with “Christian” influences. By providing Protestant religious and social services,
“Lighting the Pathways” 11
WMS missionaries worked to extend the mission’s influence into the community.
Community mission work in Smoky Lake also emphasized reli- gious, national, and social goals. Missionaries served settlers in many ways, by caring for the sick, treating toothaches, reading and writing letters, and holding youth club meetings. By assisting the Ukrainian settlers in whatever way they could, they attempted to demonstrate what a “Christian Canada” should be. These activities included “edu- cational” services such as kindergartens. In 1935-36 Mary Mansfield and Eva Empey expressed joy at the apparent success of their kinder- garten: “The little ones learn English and were happy to say that they make excellent progress when they start to school,” coincidentally providing missionaries with access to the children’s homes.?2 And they took over from the ministers’ religious education classes in the rural public schools. Iva Newton and Mary Mansfield lamented that children, not parents, decided whether to attend these optional, after- school classes and, in some cases, parents opposed teaching by Protestant missionaries. Conversely, they felt that parents appreciated their initiative and, again, that it provided access to the homes of the students—by providing the missionaries with another reason to visit families in the homes. Moreover the children “enjoy[ed] the hymns and stories and often tell their parents the story when they go home from school. ...We leave Sunday School papers in each school and the children take them home. . . .”%3
WMS missions also extended their concern to Ukrainian “girls” and young women who migrated to Edmonton to seek employment. As with other middle-class women of the period, they worried that many young, rural, and immigrant women who sought employment in the cities might soon fall in with “bad” company, and become pros- titutes.*4 In an effort to ensure that young women from the Ukrainian “colonies” of eastern Alberta did not share this fate, Margaret Sher- lock Ash opened a room for “Ruthenian” girls in the Lee Building on Jasper Avenue. Volunteers operated a night school to teach English to young Ukrainian women who worked as domestics or in the restau- rants in the city and provided limited shelter to them when they first arrived in the city or while temporarily unemployed. By October 1908 the work expanded to a rented building on Rice Street with two mis- sionaries, Reta Edmonds and Jessie Munro and their housemaid, Mary Bilar, all from Wahstao.
The mission began as an experiment. After holding mothers’ meet- ings, which were not promising, these Methodist women turned their attention to younger girls. The pattern at the Edmonton mission repli-
12 Michael Owen
cated that of the missions in eastern Alberta. “At the beginning it was simply a sewing lesson; after a short time we began the singing of hymns and an occasional Bible story, but our usual closing is with a Bible story, hymn and the Lord’s Prayer.” Moreover mission society members believed that it was necessary to do more for the servant girls who worked in middle-class homes.°5 Staff helped “mistresses” who had trouble with their “servant girls,” responded to requests from girls who “occasionally seek . . . [spiritual] private talks,”36 and visited “girls” when sick or in trouble. The mission became a social, educational, and religious centre, and a temporary lodging. To meet an apparent need, a second mission was opened up in Norwood in 1909 and another on the Fraser Flats. By the autumn of 1912, respond- ing to demands on limited resources, the Woman’s Missionary Society consolidated work in the “Ruthenian Home” and expanded its resi- dential facilities.
“Ruthenian Home” clients were young women, aged from thirteen to their late twenties. Many were referred to the home through Methodist missions in Smoky Lake or Pakan. Others located the “home” by word of mouth, as an employment agency or a place to stay where “[a] girl can rent a room for the nominal fee of ten cents a night” and could have meals “at ten cents a meal. If she cannot pay she is never refused. Besides transients there is [sic] a number of young girls in residence whose support is provided by the WMS.”37 While reasons for using the home varied, all abided by the rules of the Home, which, according to Jessie Munro, were “strict, and the improvement in the conduct, of those who needed such improve- ment, most marked. .. .“38 In 1912, the Edmonton “Ruthenian Home and School” had twenty-one roomers, most of whom worked in restaurants and were transient. While rescue work and care for the sick continued, providing access to education was the central activity of the Ruthenian Home.
Missionaries took pride in the success of their charges. In 1928, Miss Gray reported that of twenty-eight girls who had resided “at the Ruthenian home taking public and High School work... two are teaching in McDougall Sunday School, one is at Camrose Normal School, one is entering Lamont Hospital [for training as a nursel, [and] one is a worker at Kolokreeka.”3? The pattern of attendance gradually shifted from younger to older girls. In 1925, J.E. Sutherland noted the absence of primary girls and reported that “all are taking Grades XI and XII and a commercial course [and] with the exception of a very few they are attending [the United Church] Alberta Col-
“Lighting the Pathways” = 13
lege,” not the public schools in the district.40 Mrs. Sutherland praised the work resulting in two girls graduating from nursing as an exam- ple of what the church mission had accomplished. While ensuring access to schooling through the public school or Alberta College was the central function of the Edmonton mission, community or social service had been a component of the work since its opening. The goal was to make the home attractive to young Ukrainian women and to serve their needs. English language instruction and employment advice were two services attractive to Ukrainian girls and young women. Methodist and United Church women missionaries believed that among the attributes that hindered the progress of the Ukrainian woman was illiteracy, by which they meant an inability to read, write, and speak English properly. Miss Gray, in 1918, claimed that many girls “do not know English and do not see the need of learning,” as the need for English in the ethnic cafés was not pressing.4! Yet to Methodist missionaries, English was essential if these Ukrainian young women were to assimilate into Canadian society. Gray, echoing the opinion of many WMS members, urged “the Government [to] set a standard in English education before granting the franchise to these people.”42 Employment work continued throughout the existence of the mission. Although mission workers, reflecting their middle-class origins, decried the reliance of the Ukrainian women on work in cafés rather than domestic work, they understood why café work was more attractive than the drudgery and lack of privacy attendant with paid domestic work.43 “Most girls prefer Cafe work as it is only an eight hour day. They learn to be competent in a short time doing only one thing. ... The large wages and short hours at the Cafes appeal to the girls [yet] they seem unconscious of the dangers.”44
However, mission workers reached out to Ukrainian domestic and café workers, providing them with club activities along CGIT lines, sewing classes, lectures on issues of personal hygiene and temper- ance, and religious services. These activities, along with outdoor camps, were similar to and supportive of the work of the YWCA with which it was amalgamated in 1937. By the early 1930s, the home had transferred its external religious and social services to the All People’s Mission. Gradually the number of Ukrainian girls from the country who required or took advantage of the home dwindled, reflecting improved educational services in the rural region, as financial condi- tions tightened and as Ukrainian institutions became more wide- spread. By the mid-1930s the school had lost its “Ruthenian” charac- ter and was opened to any girl, “Anglo-Saxon or non-Anglo-Saxon,
14 Michael Owen
who cannot otherwise have an opportunity for pursuing her [high school] education .. .”45 Mae Laycock reported that the school home could not be filled with “New Canadian girls, due to financial condi- tions in the rural districts.” The society therefore “extended th[is] same privilege to Anglo-Saxon girls in outlying districts.” Laycock claimed this new arrangement gave Anglo-Saxon girls “opportunity .. . living and working co-operatively with those of other nationalities, under Christian influence. To know and appreciate each other and build up friendships on a basis of Christian living is a great step in the unifying of Canadian life.’”46
School homes closed as public schools became more common and easily accessible. In 1937, an era ended with the closing of the Ruthen- ian School Home in Edmonton and the school home at Wahstao. These Alberta school homes, as Jean Gordon Forbes and Winnifred Thomas had reported in 1938, were “outpost schools,”47 outposts of Canadian nationalism and modified Anglo-Protestant Christianity.
Conclusion
As early as 1926 the WMS recognized that overt assimilationist efforts were ineffective among the Ukrainians in western Canada. The WMS leadership believed that there was “no more effective way . . . for pro- viding Christian leadership for non-Anglo-Saxon colonies than the School Home... [If] China can only be saved by the Chinese, Africa by the Africans; can we not equally realize that the great majority of the strangers within our gates can only be reached by those of their own nationality!” Hence, Ukrainian children, as “the citizens of to- morrow” who resided in WMS School Homes were thought to be “the leaders of these people within Canada.” While underlining the pri- macy of the nation-building role of the school homes, WMS mission- aries expected that as Anglo-Saxon youth gradually comprised larger proportions of the homes’ clientele, “the free mingling of young peo- ple from all racial groups afford{ed] the greatest possible Canadianiz- ing influence. The divisions of the Old World will be forgotten in the camaraderie of the New, .. . leaving behind ail distinction of race.”48 However, in their own assessment, WMS members argued that the school homes, “caring mostly for our New Canadian children,” gave many young women “an opportunity of receiving an education which develops them in Christian womanhood[.]” They desired that these young women would become “ready for service, passing on to
“Lighting the Pathways” = 15
others what they have received.”4? WMS missionaries and leaders recognized that assimilation must give way to integration, that they must “bridge barriers of class and race by sincere friendship” and help “people who are in need.” While they acknowledged New Cana- dians should “retain their love for their own cultural background” and make significant contributions to Canadian life, it was to be done within a Christian context. “The aim of all the activities,” the 1935 report stated, was “to interpret the Christian way of life to those who do not know Him; to develop Christian character; and to lead boys and girls and men and women into the fellowship of the Christian Church.”°0
To achieve this goal, the WMS mission enterprise shifted from Christian evangelism to evangelical Christian community service. Being, and always remaining, staunch Canadian nationalists with a strong evangelical Protestant agenda, they argued that all immigrants needed to be remade into Canadians along the lines of the Anglo- Protestant middle class. WMS missionaries urged upon the church a more tolerant attitude toward Ukrainian Canadians. As carly as 1920, Yarwood cautioned against ethnocentrism when she spoke of “the heart cry of these people against being called foreigners when they have been born in Canada and are trying to be good Canadians.” Yarwood informed Alberta Branch members of the history of struggle of the Ukrainian people in Europe and, more recently, of the revival of religious enthusiasm in Canada, especially with the formation of the Ukrainian Greek Orthodox Church. “The word of God is read and talked about,” and she pleaded “for the warm hand of welcome and heart to love for these people.”>! From time to time missionaries raised a warning cry that the church could undermine its initiatives by being too strident in its “Canadianism” and evangelicalism. Fif- teen years later, Mrs. Thomas Powell, president of the Alberta WMS, reinforced this message and argued for “an abandonment of superior attitudes on the part of English speaking people, and...a finer appreciation of the fine background of character and accomplishment of the new Canadian in our land.”54
By 1940, “the tide [of evangelical missions had] reached its peak and [was] receding.”°3 The society needed new initiatives to carry on its work. It maintained school homes in Spedden, Bonnyville, and Vegreville but those were limited in scope. Medical missions (hospi- tals) and community missions served communities in which they were located, but as government and Ukrainian community services expanded, the need for the WMS missions decreased. As the society
16 Michael Owen
reflected on its years of service in Alberta, its members pointed with pride to the people whom it assisted: the children who received an education, the lonely women for whom quilting bees were important social gatherings, even if they listened patiently to evangelical talks by the “foreign” missionaries, the sick who were cared for, the chil- dren and young women for whom CGIT and other clubs permitted integration into Anglo-Canadian society, the young women for whom the “Ruthenian Home and School” in Edmonton provided cheap lodgings, education, and employment.
WMS missionaries in Alberta provided services to Ukrainian- Canadians at a time when these services were required and govern- ments did not provide them. Missionaries counted few conversions, no doubt because they were seen by the Ukrainians as agents of the dominant society who sought to assimilate them into a narrow vision of what it meant to be Canadians. The impact of missionaries and their institutions on the lives of Ukrainian settlers was mixed, a legacy that continues to this day. There remains a need to investigate further the interactions between women church workers and immi- grant women, to understand more fully the motivations and responses, as both attempted to come to terms with the agenda of the other.
Michael Owen is director, Research Services, at the University of Saskatchewan. His research focusses on western Canadian educational and church history with an empha- sis on the relations between Canadian institutions and ethnic minorities. Michael has published articles in a range of educational studies journals and edited collections, as well as being book review editor of Canadian and International Education and coeditor with Denis Wall of Distance Education and Sustainable Commumty Development (Edmon- ton: Athabasca University and the Canadian Circumpolar Institute, 1992).
The author acknowledges the support of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council and Canada Multiculturalism and Citizenship, Ethnic Research Program.
Notes
1, Edith Weekes Leonard, The Austrian People (Edmonton: n.d ), p. 5. For other con- temporary accounts of Methodist work among European immigrants to eastern Alberta, see W.H. Pike, “Ruthenian Home, Edmonton, Alberta” (Toronto: Methodist Church, Woman’s Missionary Society, n.d.); Mrs. W.H Graham, Forty- four Years’ Effort of the Woman's Missionary Society of the Methodist Church, Canada, 1881-1925 (Toronto: Methodist Church, Canada, Woman’s Missionary Society, 1925); Nellie McClung, “An Insistent Call” (Toronto: Methodist Church, Canada, Woman’s Missionary Society, n.d.); Will H. Pike, “Work Among the Ruthenians: Is It Worth while?” Christian Guardian (20 October 1915), pp. 8-9.
2. United Church of Canada (hereafter UCC) Yearbook (1934), p. 135. Emphasis added.
3. The activities of women as missionaries have been studied extensively over the last decade. While much of the focus of this scholarly work has been on women in the foreign mission fields, some work has focussed on women as administrators and missionaries in the home field. A small sample of the work done in Canada and the
22
“Lighting the Pathways” = 17
United States includes: Ruth Compton Brouwer, New Women for God: Canadian Pres- byterian Women and India Missions, 1876-1914 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1990); Robert Price Beaver, American Protestant Women in World Mission: A History of the First Feminist Movement in North America (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1980); Carol Lee Bacchi, Liberatwn Deferred? The Ideas of the English-Canadian Suffragists, 1877-1918 (Toronto. University of Toronto Press, 1988), pp. 59-62; Barbara Welter, “She Hath Done What She Could: Protestant Women’s Missionary Careers in Nine- teenth Century America,” Janet Wilson James, ed, Women in American Religion (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1980), pp. 112, 117-25; Wendy Mitchinson, “Canadian Women and Church Missionary Societies: A Step Towards Independence,” Atlantis 2 (Spring 1977), pp. 57-75.
Carl Berger, The Sense of Power: Studies in the Ideas of Canadian Imperialism, 1867-1914 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1970); R.C. Brown and R Cook, Canada 1896-1921. A Nation Transformed (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1974), pp. 26-82; Douglas Owram, The Promise of Eden: The Canadian Expansionist Movement and the Idea of the West (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1980)
Manilyn Barber, “The Assimilation of Immugrants in the Canadian Prairie Provinces, 1896-1918: Canadian Perception and Canadian Policies” (Ph.D. diss., University of London), pp. 72-120, Jaroslav Petryshyn, “Canadian Perceptions of the North-west and the East Europeans, 1891-1914: The Case of the Ukrainians,” Journal of Ukrainian Studies 6, no. 2 (Fall 1981), pp. 43-65.
Graham, Forty-four Years’ Effert, p 10.
. Missionaries rarely remained long in ther appointments. Some like Jessie Munro
left the field after one or two years because of ill-health Others, like Edith Weekes, married either ministers who served a charge in which the woman missionary was stationed or a local man Since married women with husbands were not considered missionaries, all WMS workers who marmried were “lost” to the field Those who married ministers may have remained in the field but as unpaid and rarely acknowledged matrons of the parsonage rather than as active missionaries. Their stories remain untold and their work invisible.
WH Pike, “The Flame—A Story of the Church’s Ukrainian Work in Alberta” (unpublished ms., 1966), p 8.
. Methodist Church, Canada, Woman's Missionary Society, Annual Report (Toronto:
1907-08), p. Ixxxvi (hereafter MCC, WMS, AR). MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1907-08), p Ixxxvi MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1909), p. civ
. See M.H. Marunchak, The Ukrammian Canadians: A History (Winnipeg /Ottawa:
Ukrainian Academy of Arts and Sciences in Canada, 1982).
. MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto. 1911), p. cxiti
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1912-13), p cxva. MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1912-13), p. cxiii
. Ibid. . MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto. 1912-13), p cxi.
UCC Yearbook (Toronto: 1933-34), p. 281. Also see Provincial Archives of Alberta (hereafter PAA) 75.387/327 UC 172/3 Box UC 11, UCC, WMS, Alberta Branch (hereafter AB), Minute Book, Seventh Annual Meeting (24-26 May 1932)
. MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto. 1908-09), p. cu.
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto 1908-09), p_ cxii.
For a discussion of these missions from a different perspective, see Vivian Olender, “Save Them for the Nation’: Methodist Rural Home Missions As Agencies of Assimilation,” Journal of Ukraiman Studies 8, no 2 (Winter 1983), pp 38-51; and Vivian Olender, “The Canadian Methodist Church and the Gospel of Assimila- tion,” Journal of Ukrainian Studies 7, no. 2 (Fall 1982), pp. 61-74.
PAA, 75 387/340 Box 12.
35.
36
37.
38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43.
Michael Owen
. For discussion of the state of education in rural Alberta in the early twentieth cen-
tury, see Paul Voisey, Vulcan. The Making of a Prairie Community (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988), pp. 180-86; M.H. Marunchak, The Ukrainian Canadians: A History, pp. 441-48, 625-31.
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1911-12), p. cxiv.
. Ibid. . MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1907-08), pp. cix-cx.
PAA, 75.387 /327 Box UC 11, WMS, AB, Annual Meeting (4-6 June 1918).
. MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1911-12), p. cxvni. . MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1912-13), pp. cxiv-cxv.
UCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1929), p 257.
. PAA 75.387/327 Box UC 11, WMS, AB, Annual Meeting (1932)
UCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1935-36), p. 340.
. UCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1939-40), p. 69.
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1909-10), p cvi. The Canadian Protestant churches were very concerned about the extent of prostitution in Canadian cities, especially among young women who migrated to the cities from rural towns or who were recent immigrants. See Mariana Valverde, The Age of Light, Soap, and Water Moral Reform in English Canada, 1885-1925 (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1991), pp 77-128 and M Owen, “‘Web of the Net of Sin’: Presbyterian Response to Sexual Immorality in Canada, 1905-1915,” Canadian History of Education Association meetings (Toronto: 1981).
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto. 1908-09), pp Ixxxviii-Ixxxix.
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1909-10), pp. cvil-cvui
W.H Pike, Ruthenian Home, Edmonton, Alberta (Toronto: WMS, MCC, n.d.), pp 2-3; MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1909-10), p. cvii.
MCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1909-10), p. cviil
PAA, 75.387 /327 Box UC 11, MCC, WMS, AB, Annual Meeting (21-24 May 1926). UCC, WMS, Annual Report (Toronto. 1925), p. 286.
PAA, 75 387, UCC, WMS, AB, Annual Meeting (4-6 June 1918).
Ibid.
For a scholarly discussion of the servant problem, see Marilyn Barber, “The Servant Problem in Manitoba, 1896-1930,” Mary Kinnear, ed, First Days, Fighting Days: Women in Manitoba History (Regina: Canadian Plains Research Center, 1987), pp. 100-19. To witness the mixed response of middle-class women to the demands of their employees, see Glenbow Alberta Archives, M1703 Box 3 File 24(), Local Council of Women, Calgary, Minutes 1919-1924 In these minutes, the LCW responded to the petitions of the Housekeepers’ Association, an association of women workers.
. PAA, 75 387, UCC, WMS, AB, Annual Meeting (Toronto: 4-6 June 1918) . UCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1935-36), p. 300.
. UCC, WMS, AR (Toronto: 1933-34), p. 273
. Yearbook (1938), p. 148.
Yearbook (1926), p. 350
. Yearbook (1938), p 147.
Yearbook (1935), p 174. PAA Accession Number 75 387, MCC, WMS, AB, Twelfth Annual Meetings (8-10 June 1920).
. UCC, Alberta Conference, Record of Proceedings (1935), p. 24. . Yearbook (1940), p. 169.
CATHERINE C. COLE ANN MILOVIC
Education, Community Service, and Social Life
The Alberta Women’s Institutes and Rural Families, 1909-1945
A little before noon she lit the lamp. Demented wind fled keening past the house: a wail through the eaves that died every minute or two. Three days now without respite it had held. The dust was thickening to an impenetrable fog.
She lit the lamp, then for a long time stood at the window motionless. In dim, fitful outline the stable and oat granary still were visible; beyond, obscuring fields and landmarks, the lower of dust clouds made the farmyard seem an isolated acre, poised aloft above a sombre void. At each blast of wind it shook, as if to topple and spin hurtling with the dust-reel into space... .
Her eyes all the while were fixed and wide with a curious immobility. It was the window. Standing at it she had let her fore- head press against the pane until the eyes were strained apart and rigid. Wide like that they had looked out to the deepening ruin of the storm. Now she could not close them.
The baby started to cry. ...
Sinclair Ross
Sinclair Ross’s poignant story of a woman losing her mind as she struggled with loneliness, poverty, and drought during the Great Depression is a powerful reminder of the obstacles people faced in the west in this period. For women, “with two rooms to live in—once a
19
20 C. Cole & A. Milovic
month to town and nothing to spend when they got there,” the sense of isolation and futility could be overpowering.! From its beginnings in 1909 to the end of the Second World War, the Alberta Women’s Institute (AWI) was important to rural women in several ways. It enabled them to face the loneliness of farm life in the early years by providing a social outlet, an opportunity to meet women from sur- rounding farms and share common concerns. Women improved their domestic skills and developed an expanded sense of home and com- munity. The community work in which AWI branches became involved, particularly during the two world wars, was widely seen as an acceptable means to broader public participation for women.
The Women’s Institutes were founded in Ontario in 1897 by Ade- laide Hunter Hoodless. Hoodless was distraught when her infant son died from drinking unpasteurized milk. She felt that women needed more information about infant care and other domestic duties. Mar- garet Graham, a settler from Ontario, founded the first institute west of the Great Lakes in Lea Park, Alberta, on 3 February 1909. This insti- tute encouraged the growth of other institutes around the province, and by 1915 a provincial organization was formed. About one hun- dred delegates, representing approximately fourteen hundred women, attended the first provincial convention later that year. In 1920, the AWI had 265 institutes with a total membership of 13,150.2 At its peak in 1921, the United Farm Women of Alberta, a partisan organization, had 309 locals which represented only 4,536 women.?
The AWI was by no means the only women’s voluntary association in the province around the turn of the century, although it was often the first organization established in a community. The AWI was uniquely suited to the needs of rural women. While other groups such as the Imperial Order of Daughters of the Empire, the Women’s Christian Temperance Union, the Victorian Order of Nurses (VON), and the United Farm Women of Alberta (UFWA) dealt with political, social, and economic issues, the AWI was deliberately nonsectarian and nonpartisan. The membership of the AWI and other groups often overlapped, allowing alliances to be formed among individual insti- tutes and other groups, in particular, the UFWA.
There were several distinctions between the AWI and the UFWA. The AWI was a transplanted organization which originated in Ontario, whereas the UFWA began on the prairies. Membership in the AWI was open to all women, whereas members of the UFWA had to be wives or daughters of male farmers. As well, the AWI was offi-
The Alberta Women's Institutes 21
cially nonpartisan while the UFWA was the women’s branch of United Farmers who formed the government in Alberta from 1921 to 1935. The AWI addressed issues related to its motto—” For Home and Country”; whatever touched home or country, touched AWI.
Through self-education, community, and war work, the AWI had a strong impact upon family life. However, this aspect of the AWI has received scant attention in earlier studies. The role of the AWI in pro- viding a social outlet for prairie women was very important. In 1913, Margaret Graham recalled the early meetings of the Lea Park branch, and wrote that:
It was common then to see a sleighload of women and children, drawn by a team of oxen, attending those first meetings. Children have always been numerous and heartily welcomed. We have had them present at two weeks old. Elderly women are less common, probably not more than one or two over fifty.4
The institutes had to overcome logistical details such as not being able to use the teams on summer afternoons because they were required in the fields. In some areas, summer meetings were switched to evenings and held alongside the UFA meetings so the family could attend together.>
In 1920, Emily Murphy looked back upon the history of the Women’s Institutes and reflected that,
The Women’s Institutes arose out of the needs of lonely women on isolated farms. These women desired to meet at stated periods for the exchange of counsel and amenities, to say nothing of the opportunity of exchanging recipes, dress patterns and community news.®
Similarly, in a 1921 review of the history of her own institute in Daysland, provincial president Isabel Nobel said that the primary idea was a social one:
Here too was an opportunity of getting together in pleasant social affairs throughout the years. And what can give a finer feeling of contentment and satisfaction to the mother of the family, than to fare forth to a meeting, where she is to meet others who have her problems, where she is to hear something for the betterment of the
22 C Cole & A. Milovic
health and education of her family, and to wit where she can wear her new dress and hat, of the latest mode, that she has learned to make at the sewing or millinery course—at minimum cost, too?”
For many women, the institute was a reprieve from the isolation they experienced on the farm.
Myrtle Heyer (formerly Roberts, who was provincial secretary dur- ing much of this period), wrote in a recent letter about her early expe- riences as a farm wife. She was active in the WI as a child because her mother had been a member in Fort MacLeod and later Drumheller. She claimed that the WI was her source of social life in the early years of her marriage.
I fell in love with a local farmer, married him and spent my life on the farm we had bought and there raised our family.
I did not know how to do anything but with the help of a very wonderful husband I did learn how to be a wife, mother, helper and also became an all around chore boy and “go for.”
The Institute was held at the members’ homes and the husbands took their wives and also the children not attending school. Every- one stayed for the afternoon. Lunch was served to all outdoors unless the weather was bad then all found a place inside—if the home was large enough, if not in the barn or outbuilding of some kind. Unless it was very cold or the snow too deep Institute was held as scheduled.
In our institute, I was the only one that ever went by horseback, but that I did, also took my two little girls with me, one in back of me the other in front. That was the way I went if the roads were too bad to go with a horse and buggy or cart.8
Involvement in the Alberta Women’s Institutes meant different things to each woman. In an address at Queenstown, Alberta, 20 May 1914, Mrs. W. Bertrand spoke about “What club life is doing for the country woman.” She suggested that
Club life is giving us a more correct perspective of our duties. We are becoming interested in current events, reading, music and the study of domestic science.
The greatest value of club life, however, lies in the social element.?
The Alberta Women's Institutes 23
Many of our informants stressed the social function of the WI. Women often joined as brides, or shortly after moving to a new community, because they wanted to meet other women the same age who shared similar experiences.
A further way the AWI affected rural families was through its members, who (as wives and mothers) passed on their experiences to their families. The institute could be a supportive group emotionally. One informant told the story of a woman who had had a disagree- ment with her husband. Afterwards, she discussed the disagreement with her friends and realized that other women had had similar prob- lems. By the time she returned home, both she and her husband had calmed down and placed the problem in perspective.!0 The meeting provided a way for the woman to escape the isolation and monotony of the farm and benefit from the experience of her peers.
Involvement in the AWI also affected other family members. One woman who joined a few years after her marriage, said that
When I started, | took my two little girls. I had to because we couldn’t afford babysitters for one thing, and I took my mother-in- law ... she enjoyed it so we were off to the meetings together .. . she'd hold one of them or the other.!!
Preschool-age children often went to meetings with their mothers. Their fathers were too busy working on the farm to look after them as meetings took place in the afternoon, the prime farming time. Much of this period was taken up by the hardships of two world wars and the Depression, when conveniences like babysitters were unavailable or unaffordable. Hence, the children often attended meetings at their mother’s side. Usually there were many preschoolers at the meetings and after school they would be joined by older children who would arrive in time for the lunch. Several of the women interviewed for this study attended WI meetings with their mothers, then later joined themselves.!2 Through this family involvement, the AWI had influ- ence within rural families.
As for husbands, if the members lived far from the meeting, “say twelve or more miles, the men would go and have their visits too, you know, they’d go off in another room and visit there.”!3 The men would have their own “meeting,” which was a social time, and just as much an answer to the isolation of the farm for the husbands as the AWI meetings were for the wives. Even if the husbands went home
24 C. Cole & A. Milovic
during the meeting, they would return in time to have lunch before taking their wives home.!4 Men in general were supportive of their wives’ involvement in the AWI. One woman commented that the men did not dare plan anything for the second Thursday of each month because they knew that it was institute meeting and that they would have to take their wives to the meeting.!5 Another husband joked that he always knew when it was institute day because lunch was ready on time so his wife could get away early. If men were not present at the meeting, they would still learn what had transpired:
When you went home you would discuss... the different things that you learned. The men were very, very interested in the Women’s Institute. ... and I think women at that point were inter- ested in all aspects of the farm life.!6
Another vital aspect of the AWI from 1909 to 1945 emerged out of the educational aspects of the institute meetings. Many of the corre- spondence courses, guest lectures, and papers that members prepared described how to improve farm life and living standards. Presenta- tions were given by local members, area residents, and, on occasion, visiting speakers. Topics addressed covered a broad spectrum, rang- ing from table setting and serving to the planting of trees and shrubs, contagious diseases, labour saving devices, butter making, patriotism, and canning and preserving. Information from lecturers on “poultry raising,” “better nutrition for the rural family,” and even “the extermi- nation of the housefly” was applied in the home.
Short courses in domestic science were offered by the Department of Agriculture. These courses included a mixture of demonstrations and lectures about cooking, care of the sick, maternal care, first aid, child care, and sanitation. If an AWI member learned how to make cheese, her family could benefit from more and cheaper cheese in its daily diet. Where a particular institute had taught the principles of quilt making or some other handicraft, these skills could be practised in the home setting and the rural family could benefit from the knowledge gained through the AWI.
The emphasis upon domestic science remained strong, as those were the questions that “most nearly concern us.” However, women were also interested in expanding their knowledge of political issues. Isabel Nobel, provincial president, demonstrated the growing politi- cization of the AWI members as a result of the suffrage campaign. She suggested, in 1919:
The Alberta Women’s Institutes 25
Don’t you think we have, for the time at least, discussed thor- oughly enough how to keep the young, the value of cheerfulness, and how to destroy the housefly—all very important we must admit, but might we not to good advantage take up this year the study of history of our Province or learn something concerning our laws and government.!7
When women obtained the franchise in 1916-17, the AWI expanded its educational program to include more discussion of political issues. The Prairie Circle Institute commented that:
We are glad to learn that women are taking a keen interest in these questions, for now that we are to take an active part in the affairs of our province, it behooves us to really know things—espe- cially things that so vitally concern us.!8
Also, in the 1923 annual report, the convenor of the Legislation Com- mittee, Adelaide Montgomery, called upon all members to
become acquainted with the legal position of the married woman, and strive to create public opinion to secure some legal recognition of the monetary value of the wife’s labour in her home.!9
Although the members were often concerned in the 1910s and 1920s with legislation that solely affected women and children, they also realized that they would be a more effective lobbying force if they looked at legislation in a wider societal context. In her 1927 report, Montgomery commented that
Our laws should be for the good of all, and if they are for the common good they will benefit any particular class of individuals if it should be benefited. Moreover, much legislation which on the surface does not appear to be concerned with the interest of women and children may in reality be of vital importance to them. ... Let ‘laws for women and children’ not become a hack- neyed expression.20
This “wider view” became apparent in subsequent reports and reso- lution of the Legislation Committee as the members began to look at issues such as women members of the Senate, the Old Age Pension Act, Alberta’s jurisdiction over its own natural resources, and the
26 C. Cole & A. Milovic
Bank Act. The committee finished its reports in 1943 with a discussion of the progress of the war.2!
Other topics, such as International Relations, were likewise impor- tant to rural women. These issues were applied to farm life by placing the farm and the importance of rural communities within the world context. This way, the institute member, and in turn her family, learned what was going on in the world; she learned what events such as war, peace, and economic changes meant in relation to them.
Women faced a number of obstacles in their efforts to become self- educated. One noted that she joined the AWI because “I was inter- ested in adult education and I thought this was a good way to further my education that | wasn’t able to get otherwise.”22 Libraries were few and far between; in many cases they were later established by branches of the WI. After 1914, the Department of Agriculture would send travelling libraries, containing books about women’s work, to Women’s Institutes.
The Women’s Institutes were engaged in a variety of community projects, some regionally specific and some more general. For exam- ple a common project in the late 1910s was the establishment of com- munity restrooms.2? Initially restrooms were intended to be a place for country women, a rest room and a quiet place for their young chil- dren to nap when the women came to town to run errands. Usually they had facilities to make a cup of tea and provided other comforts. In some communities the restroom incorporated a community club room, a place to hold meetings, band practices, concerts, receptions, cooperative markets, hospitals, and a reading room, which housed the village library. During the war they frequently served as the head- quarters for Red Cross and Field Comforts work. By the spring of 1919, thirty-two restrooms had been established in towns throughout Alberta.24
Another common project at this time was the recruitment of nurses for isolated areas. In 1914, the AWI distributed a nursing bulletin offering practical suggestions for nursing the sick which was reprinted in the Farm and Ranch Review.2> In some areas, the AW] worked cooperatively with the VON to provide nursing services to remote areas. For example, the Prairie Circle AWI expanded its restroom to allow for its use as a VON nursing station, and later a doctor's home and office, with the WI reserving some of the space for a meeting room and library. In October 1917, the Farm and Ranch Review reported that Cerea] was building a home for a nurse from the Victorian Order of Nurses:
The Alberta Women's Institutes 27
One side is to be used by the Institute and the other by the nurse. Cereal should be congratulated, as supporting a nurse for a district is one of our best lines of work.26
In 1917, Alberta became the second province to establish municipal hospitals. The intention was for these hospitals to be self-supporting within a community. Therefore, in the 1920s, the movement to secure community nurses developed into efforts to establish municipal hos- pitals. Arthur K. Whitson, secretary of the Municipal Hospitals branch of the Public Health Department considered Women’s Institutes
our greatest supporters. They are the strength of the hospital movement and the success of the organizing of municipal hospitals is due largely to the ever-zealous work of the Women’s Institutes.27
Women were eligible to serve on hospital boards from 1920, and the town of Islay lost no time in immediately electing the first female representative.
Another aspect of AWI work was the contribution the women made to home front activity during both the first and second world wars. Initially, efforts to alleviate suffering during World War I were directed toward the home front. It was a question of women helping women:
There are the wives and children of the men gone to the war. Some of these are on our farms and without the husband’s work will surely suffer want this winter. What can we do to help them?28
Margaret Phillips asked this question in her “Country Women’s Clubs” column in the Farm and Ranch Review. She appealed to women in the west to help women who were left alone, or who lived in the drought areas of the prairies, or who were in need for some other reason.
During the war, support for the war effort took many forms. For example, the Okotoks Women’s Institute pledged five dollars a month toward a Canadian prisoner-of-war. Through cooperation with the Imperial Order of the Daughters of the Empire it raised funds for “patriotic purposes.”2? Through the WI, a soldiers’ comforts associa- tion was established to send “care packages” to men overseas.*9 Fundraising during the war involved bazaars, dances, quilt raffles, and marketing other items made by the women, including the publi- cation and sale of cookbooks.
28 C. Cole & A. Milovic
Programs during the war took on a topical note as well. Papers were given on such subjects as “Why Our Boys Are Fighting,” “Women’s Work in War Time,” “Duties of a Citizen,” and “Food Con- servation.” The rationing of foodstuffs and materials was of concern to the AWL, and the institutes promoted recipes and techniques that could be used to economize. They considered these efforts to be an important sign of support for the men fighting at the front.
The AWI branches were often ready to help in a time of crisis. Whether it was aid for a drought-stricken region, food, clothing, and basic essentials for fire victims or nursing the ill, AWI members responded. During the influenza outbreak in the fall of 1918, some institutes discontinued meetings but they gave
invaluable assistance in combatting the fearful Spanish influenza epidemic that so recently swept over our country. In many towns the local Institutes installed soup and diet kitchens to supply food for the sick. They also assisted in establishing temporary hospitals, and in numerous cases donated all hospital supplies required?!
After the influenza epidemic, the WI was preoccupied with the post- war Depression. From 1919-21, institutes were largely concerned with drought relief work. A general letter was sent to all institutes asking for help. Depots were established in Calgary, Lethbridge, and Medi- cine Hat to distribute aid in the form of food, clothing, and money.*2 A wide range of community projects such as hot lunch programs for schoolchildren, beautification of cemeteries, the establishment of public libraries, town clean-up programs, well-baby clinics, fundrais- ing for school playground equipment, making “mothers’ bundles” for layettes, emergency support to fire victims, band instruments and uniforms, and clothing for needy families. A retired teacher wrote:
Words can never express the help | got from members as a teacher! One group even renovated outdoor toilets and painted the school. Help was given with annual Christmas concerts such as music, drama, candy bags and getting the tree.*3
Working together for various community projects helped women to improve their skills and gave them more confidence in their own abilities. As well, they benefited directly from access to services they worked for within a community. For example, the local history Grande Prairie: Capital of the Peace, chronicles the early achievements of the WI
The Alberta Women's Institutes 29
and emphasizes the importance of relief work during the Depression. Equally valuable was
a program that for a number of years was to prove a God-send to many country women. From April 1934 to April 1942 the Grande Prairie W.I. operated a waiting room for expectant mothers... in those eight years 319 women were accommodated for periods varying from a few days to more than three weeks.34
The AW] also established boys’ and girls’ clubs on the model of the adult institutes. Boys’ and girls’ clubs provided children with the opportunity to work alongside their mothers. These clubs were con- sidered an important aspect of children’s development as responsible citizens:
No line of work aside from war work can be of as much help to a community as the boy and girl club work and we hope after the war each branch institute will take up the boy and girl work with zeal; that and the baby welfare movement deserves much time and thought.35
Activities during the Second World War were similar to those dur- ing the Great War. A woman who had volunteered during both wars recalled the ingenuity of women trying to make the soldiers more comfortable:
We packed parcels, wrote letters to our soldiers, made quilts, packed ditty bags, and hussifs [slang for housewives, or sewing kits]. When Mrs. Parker asked us to bake fruit cakes in tobacco tins | though our home made bar soaps would not hide the odor, but she was proved right. During World War I a member suggested send- ing eggs in tins. When the top was removed our soldiers thought they were being bombed [so strong was the smell of rotten eggs].36
During the three years from 1943 to 1945, the Happy Centre WI alone produced forty-nine quilts, forty-five pairs of socks, twenty-three jackets, six wristlets, nineteen helmets, twenty-one “ditty bags,” and donated money to the Emergency Fund, the Cigarette Fund, and sent seeds to Britain.”
Through active community work the Alberta Women’s Institute has shaped the face of rural Alberta in many tangible ways. Local
30 C Cole & A. Milovic
institutes were responsible for many practical advances in community life. Members were also active in war work during both world wars. In addition to its impact upon rural family life, the AWI offered edu- cational programs for its members which improved their ability to cope with life on the farm. Through regular attendance at institute meetings members developed critical social links with their neigh- bours and an expanded social and political life. Individual members acquired knowledge and skills which allowed them to improve their home situation, build their local communities, and contribute broadly to the public sphere.
Catherme C. Cole 1» the former curator of Western Canadian History at the Provincial Museum of Alberta. She is currently pursuing a Ph.D. at the University of Leicester and working as Cultural Affairs Advisor for the Western Province of the Soloman Islands.
Ann Milovic received her M.A. in History from the University of Alberta and 1s a Ph D student at Corpus Chnsti College, Cambridge.
The authors would like to acknowledge the support of the Provincial Museum of Alberta which enabled Catherine Cole to hire Ann Milovic as a research assistant dur- ing the summer of 1989; we would also lke to thank Sylvia McInley, executive director of the AWL, for introducing us to many members of the organization, and to the mem- bers of the AWI who willingly shared their memories, time, and tea.
Notes 1. Sinclair Ross, “The Lamp at Noon,” The Lamp at Noon and Other Stories (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1968), pp. 13-23.
2. Records of the Sixth Annual Convention of the AWI, Baptist Church, Edmonton, 16 March 1920, Provincial Archives of Alberta (henceforth PAA), 75.58 5 (3); The AWI was at its peak around 1920. Figures are not available for all years but membership declined in the late 1920s and early 1930s At the end of World War I memberships expanded to include cities, and the Farm Women Institutes of Canada was formed. Membership grew from eight thousand in 1918 to mnety-five hundred in 1919 (Records of the Fifth Annual convention of the Alberta Women’s Institutes, Central Methodist Church, Calgary, 11 March 1919); In 1935, only 184 Institutes reported with a total membership of 3,532, however, information 1s contradictory in various annual reports. There may in fact have been 264 institutes at the time, some of them not reporting. Report of the Twentieth Provincial Convention of the Alberta Women’s Institutes, 24-28 May 1937, p. 21, PAA 74.1, 229, Box 9 R.W. Barritt, History of the United Farm Women December 1934, p 7, PAA 69, 193/2a Farm and Ranch Review (henceforth FRR) (20 October 1913)
Ibid.
FRR, 5 October 1920.
FRR, 15 November 1920.
Personal correspondence, Myrtle Heyer to Catherine Cole, 12 September 1989. FRR, 20 May 1914.
Personal conversation, Marie Plaizier to Ann Milovic, 5 June 1989
Personal interview, Nellie Whitson to Catherine Cole and Ann Milovic 21 July 1989,
Ned
H=SomNaAMS
—
20.
21
22
23.
24
25. 26.
27
The Alberta Women's Institutes 31
Personal interviews, Roma Simonson to Catherine Cole, 1 December 1989; Ruth Corlett to Catherine Cole, 8 December 1989.
Personal interview, Nellie Whitson to Catherine Cole and Ann Milovic 21 July 1939,
Personal interview, Roma Simonson to Catherine Cole, | December 1989
Ibid
. Personal interview, Nellie Whitson to Catherine Cole and Ann Milovic, 21 July
1989,
. FRR,5 April 1919
FRR, 5 November 1917.
. Report of the Annual Convention of Alberta Women’s Institutes and Women’s
Institutes Girls’ Clubs held in Convocation Hall, University of Alberta, Edmonton, 25, 26, 29, 30, 31 1923, p. 30, PAA 74 1, 228, Box 9
Report of the Annual Convention of Alberta Women’s Institutes held at the Univer- sity of Alberta, Edmonton, 24-27 May 1927, p. 36, PAA 74.1, 228, Box 9
See various reports of the Legislation Committee from 1927 to 1943, PAA 74 1, 228, 229, Box 9
Private interview, Nellie Whitson to Catherine Cole and Ann Milovic, 21 July 1989. Personal interviews, Roma Simonson to Catherine Cole, 1 December 1989; Ruth Corlett to Catherine Cole, 12 December 1989 and 7 February 1990,
FRR, 20 March 1919,
FRR, 5 September 1914,
FRR, 5 October 1917, in later years, the Chinook WI supported a doctor at the Cereal hospital, Minutes of Chinook WI, 6 September 1933, PAA 69.167, Box 1,5 FRR, 20 August 1920, see also Records of the Fourth Annual Convention of AWI, Hotel MacDonald, Edmonton, 9-11 March 1918, PAA 75.58.3 for reference to pro- viding headquarters for district nurses, supporting municipal hospitals, secunng doctors, and ensuring medical inspections of schools; see also Minutes of Northern Division of AWL 14 November 1917, PAA 75.58.3, when delegates decided that “Save the Babies” would be the focus of AWI in 1918.
FRR, 21 September 1914
. FRR, 5 July 1917.
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Advisory Board Meeting, 10 November 1919, PAA 75, 58, Box 1, 5.3; see also Report
of Relief Work, 1919-20, PAA 75.58, Box 1, 5.3
33. Personal correspondence, Dorothy Hosegood, née Sissons, to Catherine Cole, 18
November 1989.
. Isabel M. Campbell, Grande Pratrie: Capital of the Peace, (n.p , 1968), p 119 . FRR, 20 July 1918 . Personal correspondence, Dorothy Hosegood, née Sissons, to Catherine Cole, 18
November 1989; see Reports of Annual Conventions, PAA 74.1, Box 9, for an indi- cation of the full range of activities the AWI was involved in; see also local histories for accounts 1n specific school distnicts
Personal correspondence, Nellie Cotter to Catherine Cole, 8 November 1989
BARBARA EVANS
“We Just Lived It As It Came Along”
Stories from Jessie’s Albums
I had the privilege of meeting Jessie Umscheid and discovering her albums, filled with photographic treasures of the past, when I was researching Prairie Women, a film about farm women and the agrarian movement on the Canadian prairies in the early part of the century.! In the course of making the film, I had interviewed a number of women who had been actively involved in the struggle to bring about social and political change. As they looked back on their lives on the farm, they recalled not only the frequently gruelling work and the disappointments of crop failure and economic decline, but also the excitement they had felt at being part of the agricultural process and sharing the challenge to produce, with its myriad joys and heartaches. Through their words, they drew a collective picture of lives filled with resolution, vigour and passion, dedicated to overcoming the injustices which farm women faced. For the film, | needed photographs to rep- resent these women, both as inspiring individuals in their own right, and as representatives of a movement in which hundreds of farm women had participated, working to transform society and women’s role in it.
Photographs of the period were all too rare and those taken from a woman’s perspective almost nonexistent. As I travelled from house to house, archives to archives, asking hopefully if there might be any pictures of women’s work on the farm in the early years of settlement,
33
Jessie Umscheid, née Burk, self-portrait, 1918
Jesste’s Albums — 35
I would almost invariably be disappointed. The occasional con- strained shots I was able to find gave an overall impression of listless- ness and despondency, corresponding to the commonly held stereo- type of the farm woman as long-suffering and overburdened. These photographs, while no doubt accurate reflections of many farm women’s lives, were in no way representative of the energy and com- mitment to bring about change I had found in both the women I had interviewed and the many personal letters, diaries, and farm journals ] had read.
But the photographs in Jessie’s albums were different. Her pictures, many of which she had taken herself with her own camera, were lively depictions of farm life and women’s work on the farm. As a result, | used many of her photographs in the film and was so impressed with both them and the woman from whose albums they came that | subsequently returned to make another film, Jessie’s Albums, which deals exclusively with Jessie’s life story as she tells it through photographs and interviews.2
Jessie’s love of life and her matter-of-fact attitude toward its exi- gencies are reflected in the directness and unposed naturalness we see in her photographs, so unlike most of the pictures | had found up till then. In this short space, through her pictures and words, | hope to show not only that the depiction of any historical period depends on who has control of the means of representation but also that the pop- ular portrayal of the farm woman of the time as downtrodden, anx- ious, and unhappy with her lot is by no means universally appropri- ate.
Jessie Burk, as she then was, had been born in Baker City, Oregon in 1900, which makes her, in her words, “as old as the century.” In 1907, in common with many other Americans of the period, her fam- ily migrated to southern Alberta, settling near what was to become the town of Milo, approximately half-way between Calgary and Lethbridge, the area where Jessie still lives. The potential for wheat growing was believed to be limitless; the population was sparse and scattered.
Jessie’s life on the farm was not a particularly unusual one, but for one important factor: with her camera she had the means of recording it. She had been given the camera in 1915, as a gift for her fifteenth birthday, and had almost immediately set about taking pictures of the everyday activities of farm life. Not surprisingly, these were the jobs done mainly by women, with which she was most familiar. It was unusual for a woman of that time to own a camera, particularly a
36 Barbara Evans
Picking berries, ca. 1918
young girl in a remote rural area, and Jessie’s albums provide the closest thing to a pictorial essay of a pioneer farm woman’s life that I have yet encountered. Remarkably, although she was completely untrained in photography, her work was of a consistently high qual- ity, displaying an extraordinary sense of composition and ability to catch the transient moment.
The striking absence of dynamic photographic portraits of pioneer women in general can be attributed to a variety of factors. In the early part of the century, photography was largely a white, middle-class male preserve. Most frequently, photographs of the time showed women dressed in their bonneted, beribboned Sunday best, decked out for special occasions often associated with church-going, such as weddings or christenings, or an “official” event, such as a meeting or convention. Studio portraiture showed women surrounded by chil- dren, maternal centres of their family universe. Exotic backdrops such as Oriental rugs, plants, and expensive furniture supplied by the stu- dio bore little resemblance to the domestic environment in which the subjects actually lived. Posed, static, frozen moments, these pho- tographs were generally without personality or purpose other than to preserve for posterity, to mark and demarcate the family’s and the woman/s place in the patriarchal sphere.
If out of the studio, the action almost invariably belonged to the men; the women appeared passive, as if having nothing better to do than stand or sit demurely, waiting to be photographed, or downcast,
Jessie's Albums — 37
subjected to the tyranny of the lens and the person who operated it. “Stand still! Don’t move!” These were—and often still are—the impre- cations of the photographer to the subject. The subject’s most usual response was, not surprisingly, to strike a “suitable,” emblematic pose. For men, this was often one of proud, statuesque virility; for women, passive acceptance, in accordance with the popular sexual iconography of the time as portrayed not only in photography, but in painting and literature as well. Very few photographs showed the activities of women, or showed them dressed in everyday clothes, in everyday surroundings. This is hardly surprising, since the purpose of the family photograph was not to provide a social document, but to preserve the family’s image and relationships for future generations. Susan Sontag, writing on the photography of the period, points out:
As that claustrophobic unit, the nuclear family, was being carved out of a much larger family aggregate, photography came along to memorialize, to restate symbolically, the imperiled continuity and vanishing extendedness of family life. Those ghostly traces, pho- tographs, supply the token presence of the dispersed relatives. A family’s photograph album is generally about the extended fam- ily—and, often, is all that remains of it.5
What is surprising about Jessie’s photographs, then, is that they offer much more than a memorial to the past. Since she owned the means of photographic reproduction, she was able to choose the images she wished to preserve. Atypically, her photographs show women as sub- jects and range from thoughtful psychological studies to robust, vital, and joyful depictions of farm life. Her photographic work was doubly unusual in that it came not from the point of view of a privileged woman of means, but from the grassroots perspective of a relatively uneducated, frequently impoverished, but invariably hardworking young farm woman.
Jessie’s father and uncle had already established a homestead before the seven-year-old Jessie and her mother came to join them. Mother and daughter arrived in Alberta by train in “a howling old blizzard” in the middle of May. After staying with relatives for sev- eral weeks, they optimistically set out for the homestead with horses and wagons filled with settlers’ effects. As Jessie recalls:
We got across the hill where we could see the homestead and, of course, a prairie fire had gone over and everything was black as could be. Boy, mom was sure homesick that time. But the shack was still there, because some-
38
Barbara Evans
Jessie’s mother and sister Helen digging potatoes, ca. 1916
body had fireguarded it, where they plough a little bit or spade it out and then burn the grass on each side of it so that it protects it from burning in. The fire had jumped the fireguard, but they put it out and we had the shack, anyhow.®
Undaunted, the family proceeded to settle into their new home.
Never one to dwell upon difficulties, Jessie recounts the events in her life with the same lack of pretentiousness we find in her photographs:
Well, you just built your shack and just lived. We lived off the land as much as we could. We picked wild berries, saskatoons and strawberries, and my dad had already put out some plants, fruit bushes and things. And we had antelope meat and prairie chickens and what not.
I slept on a big packing box and we put up a tent. We lived in that until the winter drove us in the house, and then somehow or other we stacked up in this two-roomed shack.
Although this was no life of privilege, the overall impression Jessie
gives us is not one of self-pity; obstacles were regarded as challenges, merely things to get over or around. Despite hardships, life could be
Jessie's Albums 39
ite ee a
The two-roomed shack where Jessie spent much of her life
Jessie’s mother, Nellie Burk, and Jessie’s sister, Helen, feeding pigs, ca. 1915
full of fun and excitement if you let it be. Jessie’s photographs reflect her adventurous attitude toward life, while never losing their connec- tion to the daily realities farm women faced.
That’s my mom feeding the pigs. And Helen was with her, my sister. I
bought the pigs to start out with, and they all helped me raise them (see photograph above).
40 Barbara Evans
Jessie’s sister, Helen, and Jimmy, Jessie’s son, ca. 1923
WHAT KIND OF PERSON WAS YOUR MOTHER?
Oh, she was a very likeable and friendly person. Everybody that came along was her friend. Nobody left without a meal if she could help it. Of course, she would have liked to have been able to get out more.
DID SHE EVER FEEL LONELY, DO YOU THINK?
Yes, I think she did, at times. But she always sent me out to help dad and
Jessie’s Albums 41
The Burk family at harvest time, ca. 1923
to do things outside, because there wasn’t too much room in the shack, and she liked to have the room more than she did me. (LAUGHS)
She sewed and made all my clothes. And mom used to bake bread for the bachelors and wash for them and one thing and another, so we had quite a bit of bachelor company coming in.”
The invention of modern photography is dated as early as 1826, with the shadowy but temporary images of Joseph Nicéphore Niépce. The daguerreotype and other more permanent processes followed, but cameras were still the instruments of a well-to-do few. It wasn’t until the introduction in the late nineteenth century of the inexpensive Kodak camera and roll film that photography was freed from the exclusive domain of the wealthy and made available to people of more modest means. These advances provided, for the first time in history, the opportunity to record the daily lives of ordinary people which would otherwise have been unknown to those who came after. A busy farm woman like Jessie had no time to paint or draw; if she wished to document the details of everyday life, the camera was the ideal tool. Of course, handicrafts such as embroidery, needlework, and quilting were practised by farm women, but these tended to be personal and decorative, as opposed to illustrative of the wider panorama of farm life.
A number of the photographs in Jessie’s albums are self-portraits. For these, she used a home-made remote control device consisting of a string attached to a shutter release which she would pull after she
42 Barbara Evans
Jessie and her uncle, Bob Burk, on the Burk farm, Milo, ca. 1917 (sister Helen on left)
had scrambled into the frame. In the many pictures taken of Jessie by others, she was obviously comfortable in front of the camera, unlike many women of her time. Her familiarity with the photographic medium gave her an unusual consciousness and control of the image she wished to be recorded. These pictures show a strong, confident woman in a wide variety of moods ranging from quietly thoughtful to joyously extroverted, unabashed by the camera lens.
For some time after she received her camera, Jessie was sought out by members of the district to record important occasions. Because she was photographing from her own life experience, recording the people and activities which surrounded her daily, her pictures lack the voyeuristic qualities of many professional photographs of farm life. Abigail Solomon-Godeau describes the work of photographers such as Walker Evans, Dorothea Lange and Ben Shahn, members of the Farm Security Administration’s celebrated photographic project in the United States in the 1930s:
When subjects smiled into the camera, they were stage-managed into more sombre poses; sharecroppers who wore their best clothes to be photographed were told to change into their ragged everyday wear, persuaded not to wash begrimed hands and faces for the camera.8
Jessie’s Albums = 43
The Howell Family listening to the gramophone, ca. 1915
For Jessie, her subjects were not exotic beings to be conformed to an external point of view, they were part of her community.
They'd ask me to come and take some pictures for people, if they were hav- ing a family gathering or something, so I used to go to their place when- ever they would ask me, and take some.
DID THEY PAY YOU? They paid me for the pictures I took for them, yes. SO YOU WERE SORT OF THE LOCAL PHOTOGRAPHER, THEN?
Well, I don’t know whether I was good enough or not, but I answered the purpose for awhile.
Photographs taken by professionals, like those of the Farm Security Administration, were meant for public consumption. For better or worse, it is these images which most frequently shape our perceptions of the past. Photographs taken by those who actually lived the recorded experiences are more elusive.
That's one of the Howell family. They didn't have room in the house for us, so they gave us dinner on the installment plan and we'd all take out chairs and go out on the hillside and listen to the gramophone... 1 thought it would make a nice picture of everybody enjoying the outdoors, so I just backed off and took the picture (see photograph above).
44 Barbara Evans
Jessie’s sister playing with cats, Milo, ca. 1917
DID YOU TAKE YOUR CAMERA WITH YOU OFTEN?
Yes. So many people asked me to take pictures for them, I usually had it with me.
Through Jessie’s photographs and recollections, we are given not only insights into the details of daily farm life, but a perspective on the wider rural society as well.
Education was often erratic in rural areas. Since there had to be a minimum number of pupils in a district to start a school, its fate could depend on the arrival or departure of one or two families. Jessie her- self did not start school until she was nine years old because, prior to that, there had been no school. She describes the excitement felt by the community when the school opened:
We were all quite thrilled. There were people going to school from begin- ners of seven years old up to sixteen who hadn't been to school before. And when they got too much for the teacher she'd send some of the smarter ones and the better educated ones to help the little ones. But we had lots of fun at school. There were always games and exercise and what not.
I did the janitor work one year, and I carried the drinking water about a quarter of a mile from the neighbour's well. A fresh pail of water each morning, and sometimes at noon.
|
RR
ER IRD EE TELA DIET
Jessie's Albums 45
Pioneer School with teacherage and car, ca. 1915
YOU WERE ALWAYS WORKING AT SOMETHING. YOU HAD A LOT OF RESPONSIBILITY.
(LAUGHS) Yes, it just worked into my life, I guess .. .
In all my discussions with Jessie, the only note of bitterness I ever heard her express was when she talked about the disappointment she felt at being unable to finish school:
I didn’t get a very good education. Of course in those days, they didn't think that women needed an education, you know. They were just house- wives. We were not very important people.
I finished my grade eight. I was fifteen, sixteen, somewhere in there. But it was a lot of hit and miss, not really getting it thoroughly. I would have liked to have been a nurse, but it took too much education.
Over the years, Jessie’s camera captured many aspects of women’s work which usually went unrecorded. While the activities of men and threshing machines at harvest time were well-documented, women’s less visually dramatic part in the harvesting process was generally overlooked.
From an early age, Jessie worked with her mother during the busy harvest season cooking for the threshing crews which travelled from farm to farm.
Group of men and women at threshing time, Milo area, ca. 1916
Nellie Burk, Jessie’s mother, Jessie Burk and Jessie’s sis- ter, Helen, working on cook car, ca. 1916
Jessie’s Albums 47
The influenza epidemic of 1918-19
That's one of the cook cars that my mom and I cooked on. We had a bed in the corner that we slept on, the both of us together. It was just a single cot. And in the daytime we put a plastic cover on it and used it for a table. And then there was a stove across the end there that we cooked on. We'd have breakfast at five o'clock, and another one at seven. And it just kept you busy. You see, you'd have from twelve to sixteen men, usually, in a threshing outfit. We took lunch out in the afternoon. I had my pony on the buggy and Id go and take the lunches out to the field and that sort of thing. It paid us five dollars a day, and boy, that was good wages at that time. It would go on maybe for several months. If there was a break you'd lose a lot of time, and be feeding the men for nothing. I missed quite a bit of school on account of it (see photograph bottom left).
In 1918 and 1919, a deadly influenza epidemic swept over the prairies. In Canada, fifty thousand people died from it, worldwide over twenty-one million.
48 Barbara Evans
‘an
Jessie with baby Jim on “Old Prince,” 1921
Babies having dinner in field during harvesting, ca. 1923
Well everybody it just seemed like was stricken all of a sudden. Whole families came down with it at once and there was nobody to do chores or anything. Somebody’d go out to milk the cows and catch a chill or pneu- monia and that was it. It just seemed to take them off like flies.
The United Farmers of Alberta had just built a hall in Milo and they turned it into a hospital. Everybody lent their sheets, and they cut the hall in three sections. The women were on one side and the men on the other
Jessie’s Albums 49
Clarence and baby Jim with team of horses, 1922
and the children in the middle. Anybody that had a cot or a bed of any kind that they could use took it down. The schools were all closed, and the teachers nursed in the hospital. I used to go around the district and gather up food for the patients that were in there. One time we had thirty people in the hall. I helped to nurse people and was in among it a lot, and it never touched me until it was all over, and then I got it. I really had a dose of it.
In 1920, Jessie married Clarence Umscheid, who had come from Oregon to the Milo area to do seasonal work as a farmhand. By that time, Jessie’s parents had moved into a larger house on the farm prop- erty and, to save money, the newly-wed couple moved into the two- roomed shack in which Jessie herself had been raised. Over the next few years, five children were born into its confines.
At the outset of the marriage, Jessie made sketches of the house she dreamed of building when the young family’s finances improved. But, as the Depression of the 1930s loomed closer and economic con- ditions grew worse, the family was forced to remain in the shack for the next twenty years.
When Clarence and I were married in 1920, we borrowed $3,000 to get horses and things to farm with. We never got that paid off until 1950. (LAUGHS)
50 Barbara Evans
Jessie with children Bob and Jim on packing crate, ca. 1923
YOU MUST HAVE THOUGHT YOU WOULD NEVER GET IT PAID OFF.
Well, we were all in the same boat, you know. People seemed to get along without very much complaining. Just lucky to have what we did have, you know.
For much of the 1920s, Jessie’s camera was largely devoted to docu- menting her growing family.
The energy Jessie put into farm work extended to work in the com- munity and, despite her demanding work on the farm, she somehow found time to attend meetings of local groups. Like a great many other women in the district, Jessie and her mother were actively involved in the United Farmers of Alberta (UFA) and its counterpart
Jessie's Albums 51
Jessie’s mother-in-law and mother with Jessie’s sons Bob and Jimmy, Milo, ca. 1923
ve
Women riding to town in grain box pulled by horses, ca. 1918
women’s organization, the United Farm Women of Alberta (UFWA), committed to improving conditions in the rural community and par- ticularly the position of women.
We were all interested in what was going on.... When we came to this country, everything was down in Ontario, you know. Everything was for Ottawa, and we were all interested in becoming a part of Canada. I went
52 Barbara Evans
The Milo United Farm Women of Alberta go to Arrow- wood, ca. 1925
to several of the conventions in Edmonton, and one in Calgary. We had cots, you know, a bunch of us in one room. It was cheaper living that way. So we got to go to those things. We were always working and building up our UFA to have some say in the government and the like.
The Depression arrived with full force in 1929. The droughts and duststorms which accompanied the collapse of wheat prices wrought havoc and misery all across the prairies, bringing ruin to countless farms. Yet, although she and her family were severely affected, Jessie’s memories of the late 1920s and 1930s are remarkable for their lack of rancour. Her memories centre on how people coped, rather than on the deprivation they experienced:
Well, the Depression was just something that happened, and you just took it as it came. We just lived it as it came along, the same as any other thing that happens that way.
We had a beef ring. We'd each supply a beef every so often and we'd divide it up amongst twelve of us. And we had chickens and eggs so we didn’t fare too badly. We didn’t have any orange trees, but then you don’t have to have.
One year, there was no crop. Insects had moved in, and the dust and everything, and we didn’t have any crop. We sold our cattle because we
Jesste’s Albums — 53
didn’t have feed for them. And you know the funny part of it was that nobody was complaining too much. Everybody seemed to keep on the cheery side. You just kind of made do with what you had.
The Depression provided previously undreamt-of photo opportuni- ties for outside observers. Professional photographers, both in Canada and the United States, travelled to the most seriously depressed areas during the 1930s, recording the suffering they encountered there. Often, as Susan Sontag points out, they took dozens of photographs to capture “the precise expression on the subject’s face that supported their own notion about poverty, light, dignity, texture, exploitation, and geometry.”
But for Jessie, the Depression destroyed her delight in photogra- phy. Unlike the professionals, she had neither the money to take pic- tures nor the desire to record the devastations of duststorms and crop failures:
We didn’t want pictures of it. We didn’t want to spend the money on tt, for one thing. We didn’t use money for anything that we didn’t have to, because it just kept you going to keep going.
WERE THERE THINGS THAT YOU WANTED TO TAKE PIC- TURES OF?
I don’t think so. It didn't seem there was any point in taking pictures of a duststorm, nor the army worms and that sort of thing.? We didn’t think it was anything too nice to take pictures of. (LAUGHS)
THAT MUST HAVE BEEN A PRETTY BLEAK TIME. Yes, it was, but then that’s the way life goes. LIFE JUST SEEMED TOO MISERABLE, I GUESS.
I don’t know if it was so miserable, we just didn’t have the wherewithal to take them.
Throughout our discussions, both in recorded interviews and later, over the years, Jessie was consistently wary of any interpretation she feared might trap her into what she viewed as a falsely sentimental - portrayal of the past. This refusal to dramatize her experiences of farm
54 Barbara Evans
life was paralleled in the unsentimental immediacy of her approach to photography. For Jessie, it was not a question of a look, or a geometry. In representing her own life, she did not wish to be immortalized as the downtrodden, powerless woman of popular stereotype, the victim of circumstance, that outsiders, whether photographers, historians, filmmakers, or writers, have all too often presented.
This is not to diminish the hardships that farm women encoun- tered—and still encounter to this day—but rather to say that there can be no monolithic view of women’s history. Instead, we must listen to the multiplicity of voices and experiences which make up that history in order to understand it. In Jessie’s case we are fortunate to have not only her words, but also the images she created to help us uncover a part of the complex, multilayered narrative of women’s lives.
Barbara Evans, an award-winning filmmaker, 1s a graduate of the University of British Columbia and the British National Film and Television School. She has worked as a director, producer, writer, researcher, and editor of film and television. Her work deal- ing with farm women and prairie politics includes the films Pratrre Women, a film on the history of orgaruzed farm women on the Canadian prairies, In Her Chosen Field, a docu- mentary on issues facing contemporary farm women, Jessie's Albums, the story of a farm woman who documented her life through photographs in the early years of the cen- tury, and a video, Now That We Are Persons, which celebrates the sixtieth anniversary of the Persons Case. She 1s currently working on a feature-length documentary film which chronicles the early years of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation. Since 1990, she has taught film and video production at York University.
Notes
1. The film Prairie Women is distributed by the National Film Board of Canada.
2. Jessie's Albums is available from Filmwest Associates, 2399 Hayman Road, P.O. Box 1437, Kelowna, BC, V1Y 7V8.
3. All photographs included in this article have been deposited with the Glenbow Archives in Calgary and copies may be ordered from there.
4. Unless they belonged to a culture other than the predominant Anglo-Saxon one, in which case their “difference” might be emphasized by showing them in “foreign” dress, burdened by hard labour.
5. Susan Sontag, On Photography (New York: Delta, 1977), p. 9.
6. The quotations throughout this chapter are edited excerpts from interviews with Jessie Umscheid by the author on 4 August 1986 and 1 and 2 September 1987.
7. In order to provide extra income for the household, it was a common practice among farm women to bake and do laundry for bachelors.
8. Abigail Solomon-Godeau, Photography at the Dock Essays on Photographie History, Institutions and Practices (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1991), p.179.
9. Throughout the Depression, southern Alberta was plagued by crop-destroying infestations of grasshoppers and “armies” of caterpillars.
COLLETTE LASSITER JILL OAKES
Ranchwomen, Rodeo Queens, and Nightclub Cowgirls
The Evolution of Cowgirl Dress
The history of the west has been dominated by images of the male fig- ure. In American and Canadian western annals particularly those con- cerning the development of the cattle frontier, the cowboy has become an enduring mythological figure. The purpose of this paper is to exam- ine the evolution of the female counterpart to the cowboy—the “cow- girl”—by looking at the evolution of the cowgirl style of dress.
This study briefly traces the origins of the “real” cowboy, how he dressed, the functional nature of his attire, and how his image came into public favour. Over the years the cowboy/cowgirl look has diverged, with cowgirl dress becoming a less clearly defined fashion style. How the frontier woman dressed in actuality is briefly discussed in order to temper the romanticized vision history and popular culture have of the early cowgirl. That vision has changed and evolved throughout the twentieth century. From the “Wild West” shows of the turn of the century to the Hollywood Western, and the styles rodeo women have adopted throughout the decades, our culture appears to continuously recreate its version of the cowgirl.
Early Dress in Cowboy Country
The long standing love affair with the cowboy or cowgirl image in North America is perhaps as durable as the clothes the first cowhands wore.
55
56 C. Lassiter & J. Oakes
Funk & Wagnall’s New Encyclopedia defines the cowboy as
the name given to the mounted herdsmen hired by cattle owners in the United States to look after their stock. Cowboys keep the cattle together, guide them to pasture, prevent their being mixed with other droves, protect them from rustlers, brand them at the proper season, and drive them to the shipping point.!
This source adds that cowboys figure most significantly in American history from the 1850s to 1890s, “when transportation facilities were scanty in the western and southwestern sections of the U.S. and cattle had to be driven to shipping points over long distances.”* Performing such tasks ona daily basis undoubtedly called for endurance and good horsemanship; the man’s clothes would have to be functional and able to withstand inclement environments.
The working cowboy of the nineteenth century dressed appropri- ately for his work. His attire, it is said, was not fickle to the whims of fashion, “In cowboy country the fashions of apparel do not change”; “it lcowboy dress] knew nothing of variable fashion and suffered from no change in style.”4 From his hat to his boots the cowboy’s attire is functional.
Of the infamous western hat or “genuine Stetson,” Hough says the following:
There has been no head covering devised so suitable as this for the uses of the plains. The heavy boardlike felt is practically indestruc- tible ... the heavy felt repels the blazing rays of the sun better than any helmet . .. the cowboy can depend upon his hat at all seasons. In the rain it is an umbrella. In the sun it is a shade and a safeguard ... in the winter he can tie it down about his ears with his handker- chief.
Shirts were made from wool or cotton and were usually pullovers although a few used buttons. Shirts were usually checked, striped, or one solid colour, but were rarely red because “the latter tone was reputed to go badly among the cattle.”7
Denim was popularized by the working cowboy due to its inherent durability and comfort. “According to the Levi Strauss Company, the levis that appeared in Texas in the 1850s—certainly by the 1860s, were originally brown or natural canvas color; later they became blue.
Cowgirl Dress 57
Copper-riveted levis were introduced in 1872-1873, but cowboys con- sidered them a low-caste innovation and did not adopt them until the ‘90s.”8 Boots invariably had two-inch high heels.? One source describes them as
vertical at the front, and were in length and breadth much smaller at the bottom than at top. The tall heel, highly arching the wearer’s instep, insured, as did the elimination of all projections, outstanding nails, and square corners from the sole, against the wearer’s foot slipping through the stirrup or being entangled in it... the sole usually quite thick, this to grant to the wearer a semiprehensile “feel of the stirrup.”10
These items of cowboy attire, along with gloves, chaps, and a ker- chief, were chosen for the tasks at hand and to suit varying environ- mental conditions. Vanity may also have played a role. From the styles of dress portrayed in archival photographs, it is evident that many cowboys “... took pride in their appearance.”!! The cowboy and the west have often symbolized the common man and his struggles. Wilson indicates that “because cowboy dress was such an evident characteristic of the cowboy image, dressing the part elevated an indi- vidual into the heroic replica. .. .”12
The image of a tight-jeaned and booted cowboy, sporting a Stetson and a long-sleeved shirt, has varied little for more than a century. Working cowboys of the nineteenth century and the contemporary image are somewhat similar, with the exception of the Hollywood dandy-style cowboys of the 1940s and 1950s. In contrast, cowgirl dress styles, particularly the image of the woman on horseback in popular culture, has been far more dynamic. “The female garb seems to have changed primarily to reflect contemporary fashion rather than to recre- ate authentic Western fashion.” 13
Early Frontier Women
Women preparing for the journey west were advised to take no fine clothing, only “things suitable for everyday wear,” such as a “calico frock, plainly made, no hoops, and a sun-bonnet.” Some women invented garments to suit their new western chores. A few, annoyed by long skirts that forced them to ride sidesaddle while they tend-
58 C Lassiter & J. Oakes
ed cattle, dared to create outfits that permitted them to ride com- fortably astride: shorter skirts with blue denim knickers to wear underneath. !4
Thus, the “cowgirl” was created. The image of the spirited heroine on horseback in the frontier was, at least in the early days of western expansion, quite a rarity. She existed in dime novels to a greater degree than she did in reality. As Calder has indicated, “women were not a plentiful commodity in most parts of the frontier. It was often easier to import pianos and champagne than to bring out suitable mates for the frontiersman.”!> The west was dirty, rugged, often lawless; it offered few opportunities for “respectable” single women. Of the first women who did come one has only to look at their stern, wrinkled young faces, their plainly made cotton dresses, a succession of young children and perhaps a look of sombre determination. These were the first women of the west and they were not cowgirls. Of such women, Isabella Bird, a traveller and writer in nineteenth-century America states:
She looks like one of the English poor women of our childhood— lean, clean, toothless, and speaks like one of them, in a piping, dis- contented voice, which seems to convey a personal reproach. All her waking hours are spent in a sun-bonnet. She is never idle for one minute, is severe and hard, and despises everything but work.!©
Calder emphasizes that few people would recognize the above image as reflective of the life and appearance of many frontier women (Photo. 1.).
Popular culture has romanticized the female settler as the serene beautiful wife, the adventuress, or more commonly as the rancher’s pretty young daughter. Female settlers were not romanticized as range wranglers, accountants, cooks, or ranch owners. However, women eventually did come west, often as daughters, wives, and nieces,!7 who worked alongside men:
Although cattle ranching is usually portrayed in movies and tele- vision as a completely male world dominated by gun-slinging cowboys and outlaws, the cattle culture had its share of women. A number of women were wives of ranchers and worked side by side with them in keeping books, and managing the feeding of cowboy
Cowgirl Dress 59
Photo. 1. Few earlier fron- tier women could be called “cowgirls” as we have come to know them. (D. Gray, “Women on the Cattle Frontier,” Women of the West.)
employees and caring for stock. A number of women actually owned cattle ranches themselves. !8
Changing Dress Standards for Early Cowgirls
The life history of Agnes Morely illustrates the need for change in “tra- ditional” female dress in cattle country. As a teenager in 1886, Agnes Morely went to a New Mexico cattle ranch along with her mother, sis- ter, brother, and a step-father who soon after deserted the family. Agnes and her mother ran the cattle ranch themselves in order to save the family’s only fortune.!? Liberating herself from restrictive feminine clothing Agnes recounted the following:
First, I discarded, or rather refused to adopt, the sun-bonnet, con- ventional headgear of my female neighbors. When I went unashamedly about under a five-gallon (not ten-gallon) Stetson, many an eyebrow was raised; then followed a double-breasted blue flannel shirt, with white pearl buttons, frankly unfeminine. In time
60 C. Lassiter & J. Oakes
came blue denim knickers worn under a short blue denim skirt. Slow evolution (or was it decadence?) toward a costume suited for immediate needs. Decadence having set in, the descent from the existing standards of female modesty to purely human comfort and convenience was swift. A man’s saddle and a divided skirt (awful monstrosity that it was) were inevitable. This was in the middle nineties.29
Inevitably, more women became involved in cattle ranching. Some learned how to ride, rope, and shoot exceptionally well. During pre- rodeo days, cowboys or cattlehands showed off their skills to each other on early cattle round-ups. In 1847, Captain Mayne Reid, author of The Rifle Rangers, recorded:
This round-up is a great time for the cowhands, a Donnybrook fair it is indeed. They contest with each other for the best roping and throwing, and there are horse races and whiskey and wines.?!
Cowboys and a few cowgirls joined Buffalo Bill’s “Wild West” show, thereby demonstrating their skills to a wider public. As a result, cow- girl dress received broad exposure. As Swallow-Reiter points out, “Rodeo cowgirls, most of whom first learned their skills in real ranch work, encouraged public acceptance of women riding astride as well as popularizing such practical equestrian fashions as divided skirts’22 (Photo. 2.).
Androgynous Yet Fancy Styles for North America’s Rodeo Sweethearts
Annie Oakley became the “greatest personality developed by the ‘Wild West’ shows.”?3 The western frontier was fast disappearing by the turn of the century and the public adored the acts of this flam- boyant show.24 Rodeos soon gained popularity and one of the most famous rodeos, The Calgary Stampede, began in 1912. Female rodeo participants wore a loose long sleeved shirt, Jong divided skirt, (Photo. 3.), flat boots and a large light coloured Stetson. An example of these cowgirl fashions is worn by “Flores La Due, wife of the Stampede’s founder, Guy Weadick, who won the Cowgirls’ Trick Roping prize. ...”25 Flores La Due was originally from Oklahoma and a veteran of the Wild West Shows.° Dress styles of the early
Cowgirl Dress 61
Photo. 2. Cowgirl (1904-1908) (Vancouver Museum, Panache (1990-91), p. 27.)
fancy riders such as La Due at the Calgary Stampede in 1912 and “Buffalo Bill’s” beloved early show cowgirls were often identical.
By the 1920s, rodeo cowgirls wore simple blouses, “high-waisted, loose-fitting slacks (riding breeches), tight at the ankles and usually worn tucked into high-topped boots.”2” As Fenin and Everson point out, the Hollywood cowgirl of this era was also “dressed in practical blouses, and skirts were shorter. There was no longer quite the same hesitation about showing something of a well-shaped female leg, in western or other films, but fashions were still modest.”28 Martin terms the 1920s as a “kind of golden age of the show cowgirl, an innocent time” for the country’s rodeo sweethearts.2? Changes in styles of rid- ing garments made riding astride acceptable for women.
62 C. Lassiter & J. Oakes
Photo. 3. Flores La Due . . . simple blouse and trousers. (Courtesy Glenbow Archives, NA 628-2 to 4)
North America’s affection for country music began in the 1930s, “when cowboys and cowgirls began popping up on radio shows that had once hollered convincingly about their hillbilly allegiances.”9° The most memorable singing cowgirl of the era was Patsy Montana who is said to have had: “campfire-by-night eyes, and the full regalia of boots, buckskin, bandanna, and Stetson... off came the ginghams, bonnets, and down-home long dresses; out came the wardrobe of Annie Oakley.”3!
Rodeo cowgirls reflected the flamboyance of the singing cowgirls. Consider for example, Margaret (née Brazeau) Fry’s outfit which included a skirt, vest, gauntlets, boots, and even spurs. The elaborate leather fringe work, glass and steel beading, and silk lining leave one wondering if this rosebud-embellished cowgirl’s dress was even fanci- er than anything worn by emerging Hollywood or Nashville cowgirls. This ensemble was beaded by Margaret’s mother Louise Belcourt (1861-1926), a woman of French and Cree ancestry. The dress is a unique and beautiful merging of native and western ideals in dress; a sure cowgirl prize winner (Photo. 4.).
Cowgirl Dress 63
Photo. 4. Brazeau’s Decorative Work ... now a cowgirl museum trea- sure. (Courtesy Glenbow Archives, C 13282 A-D)
Hollywood Cowgirls
By the 1940s a more glamorous cowgirl look emerges. The inspiration for the new image coincides with the popularity of Roy Rogers and Dale Evans and her “cover-girl costumes in dozens of tumble-weed musicals.”32 Cowgirls at the Burns’s Chuckwagon Radio Program in Calgary, 1940, wear smaller hats than previously seen (Photo. 5.). Arched eyebrows, red lipstick, and permanent waves are “de rigueur” for these ladies of the rodeo, who were even pictured smoking and drinking. Their white outfits and costumelike hats no longer suggest any inspiration from the working ranchwoman, but rather that of star- lets. Other cowgirls at the Calgary Stampede are pictured in similar costume; however, an even more refined white hat and a tailored satin cowgirl blouse seemed more popular overall. A similar ensemble is worn by the candidate poster for a 1952 rodeo queen which reads: “Doreen Wynee—Candidate for Calgary Stampede Queen, Sponsored by the Motion Picture Industry.” The cowgirl had gone Hollywood. The cowgirl image of the 1950s continued with the trend for glam- our and femininity. Fringed skirts were worn up until about 1959. Fenin and Everson state that “short skirts and ankle boots came into
64 C. Lassiter & J. Oakes
Photo. 5. Burns’s Chuckwagon Radio Program— Cowgirl Performers Lipstick, nailpolish and “dandy style” cowgirl outfits for the rodeo girl of the 1940s. (Courtesy Provincial Archives of Alberta, Harry Pollard Collection, P 3929)
vogue by the 1950s.33 This was the era of Patsy Cline: “the Virginian who took country torch songs to the pop charts, might belt out tales of urban despair, but she’d do so wearing outfits that glittered with cow- girl glamour.”34
New Trends for the 1960s and 1970s
By 1963, rodeo queens were pictured for the first time in contour-fit- ting jumpsuits (Photo. 6.). Rodeo cowgirls and queens have predom- inantly worn pants even though earlier pant styles were made to look like skirts. It is uncertain whether this is a reflection of real change in views of women’s roles or as a result of more emphasis being placed on horsemanship, which required the use of pants. As in the 1950s, the cowgirl look mirrored Hollywood’s ideal of the cowgirl. As one source notes:
Women have changed externally in Western films during the last eight decades, with the trend always in the direction of revealing
Cowgirl Dress 65
Photo. 6. Canadian Finals Rodeo Queens (1976). Stretch polyester (?) jumpsuits on the cowgirl of the 1970s. (Courtesy Provincial Archives of Alberta, Edmonton Journal Collection, J 2851/1)
more and more of their bodies... heroines in pants and blouses calling attention to their figures.
In the early 1970s man-style suit jackets and tight pants with bell- bottom legs were adapted for rodeo queens. These fashions were worn up to about 1983, long after the style became unfashionable elsewhere. Printed fabrics and stretch polyester were used instead of leather fringe, denim, and satin. As Martin points out “no rodeo worthy of the name is complete without a rodeo queen and her attendants—each decked out in matching aqua or lavender or gold polyester pants, jack- et, and hats.”36 Miss Universe-like sashes appeared on rodeo queens of the 1970s and 1980s. Hair was generally worn long and straight and makeup was minimal, perhaps to reflect a clean, fresh-scrubbed coun- try girl ideal.
Urban Cowgirls
During the 1970s, the cowgirl image in popular culture became less popular as, “many country singers ...abandoned cowgirl duds for
66 C. Lassiter & J Oakes
approximations of folk music fashions.”3” Although rodeo queens were crowned with white Stetsons, the look was unpopular among movie stars and country singers. By the end of the decade a dramatic turnaround occurred. Tom Robbins’s novel, Even Cowgirls Get the Blues, revived the cowgirl image.° By the late 1970s, journalist Aaron Latham, working for Esquire magazine, wrote an article entitled, “The Ballad of the Urban Cowboy: America’s Search for True Grit.”
Latham had travelled to Houston, America’s newest boomtown, in search of modern-day cowboys. What he found were dead-end blue-collar workers, who lacking ... any sort of romance or success in their own lives, spend their nights in a honky-tonk called Gilley’s—which bills itself as the world’s biggest saloon—acting out their cowboy fantasies—hardhats, bread-truck drivers, accoun- tants—they pull on their Tony Lama cowboy boots, square a Stetson on their heads, and for the next few hours rope and ride and drink like the long-gone real McCoys. At least that’s how Latham saw it.°?
Paramount Pictures was equally intrigued with using the cowboy fantasy as the basis for a movie. Eventually a script was written for Urban Cowboy, which went on to become a North American box office hit. The country was once again in love with the cowboy mythology:
By the summer of 1978, Texas fever had struck every town in America.
Anything and everything that was fringed, tooled, Stetsoned, den-
imed or otherwise smacked of Texas cowboy gear was the fashion 40
rage.
Even Newsweek published a piece on the “Nightclub Cowboy” before the movie opened across the country.
The capital of urban cowboyland attracts a remarkedly diverse clientele... but their mainstays are young men who work in near- by refineries, shipyards and grain elevators, and women who toil as waitresses ... women who sport ultra-tight jeans, abundant make- up and Farrah Fawcett hairdos.?!
In the same movie Debra Winger wore straight-legged jeans and tight tank tops for her role as Sissy, a nightclub cowgirl. Critics and audi- ences adored and copied this new definition of cowgirl sexiness. Critic Pauline Kael wrote, “that she looked like she wore her clothes over
Cowgirl Dress 67
damp skin.”42 Advertisers of women’s wear took advantage of this new-found cowgirl look. Country nightclubs across the country thrived, as “wanna be” cowboys and cowgirls came wearing designer blue jeans and increasingly fancy boots and belt buckles. During Stampede week in Calgary, people from a wide variety of occupations were willing to stand in line for hours to enter western inspired night- clubs and bars. The same people were captivated by one of North America’s boldest myths. As children, many grew up in the 1950s and 1960s watching television or movies that depicted beloved cowboy fig- ures such as the freckled, bandanna-sporting puppet “Howdy Doody.” As adults, this generation remembered an era in the 1950s when young boys and girls dressed up as cowboys and cowgirls for birthday par- ties and ventured to local fairs or rodeos. Fabrics depicting the cowboy theme were not uncommon during the 1950s. They were used for chil- dren’s bedspreads or curtains. The cowboy and cowgirl ideology endures to the present day as another generation redefines an interest in the image.
Nashville to Alberta Ranch Women
Cowgirl fashions reflect contemporary fashion and a more explicit sex- uality. With the current popularity of country music at the outset of the 1990s, the cowgirl look is unashamedly “traditional” or at least tradi- tional in the sense that the look is overtly western. “The new tradi- tionalists of country music, such as performers Reba McEntire, Holly Dunn, and Kathy Mattea, are not at all averse to sporting Stetsons and other western gear for their outing in front of the public.”43 High fash- ion has embraced the cowgirl-look, creating combinations never worn by ranchwomen.
Rodeo cowgirls, such as barrel racers, are perhaps less likely to suc- cumb to the whims of fashion than are rodeo queens or entertainers. Today the “modern cowgirl (rodeo competitor) wears a colourful vari- ation of the basic western wardrobe of hats, boots, long-sleeved shirts, and close-fitting trousers.”44 Gloves that protect the cowgirl’s hands from rope burns and chaps to prevent abrading her legs against bush- es are worn. As for her male counterpart, the Canadian Professional Rodeo Association Rules require such attire as hats and long-sleeve shirts.49 Ranchwomen of Alberta continue to wear clothes reflecting practicality and harmony with the environment.
68 C. Lassiter & J. Oakes
Conclusion
In popular culture the dress of the cowgirl constantly changed with current ideals of fashion and morality. Styles have been more practical and stable for contemporary female rodeo competitors and working ranchwomen. However, North American culture views the cowboy/ cowgirl look as representative of a sort of freedom and adventure, and entailing perhaps a sense of “country” purity and tradition.
The dress of the rodeo queen, the entertainer, or the working ranch- woman may vary, but her image is as much a part of western ideolo- gy as the cowboy. As Roach proclaims in her book, The Cowgirls, “I am inclined to attach some importance to a theory . . . that the emancipa- tion of women may have begun when they mounted a good cow horse and realized how different and fine the view was.”46 The west is said to have a history of its own. The evolution of cowgirl dress reflects the double duty for women to be “feminine” and to get the job done.
Collette Lassiter has a long term interest in cowgirl dress. She is a graduate ot the Department of Clothing and Textiles, University of Alberta (1991)
Jill Oakes (B H.Ec., MSc , Ph.D., University of Manitoba) studies the meaning and evolu- tion of clothing styles within a cultural and historical perspective. She is a professor in the Department of Human Ecology, University of Alberta
Notes 1. Funk and Wagnall’s New Encyclopedia 7, .v. “cowboy,” p. 112. 2. Ibid. 3. E. Hough, “The Cowboy’s Outfit,” The Story of the Cowboy (Upper Saddle River, NJ. Literature House/Gregg Press, 1970), p. 50 4. P. Rollins, “What the Cowboy Wore,” The Coivboy: An Unconventional History of Crulization on the Old-trme Cattle Range (New York Charles Scnbner and Sons, 1936), p 103. 5 Hough, “The Cowboy's Outfit,” p. 54 6. Rollins, “What the Cowboy Wore”, D. Gorsline, “The Cowboy,” What People Wore: A Visual History of Dress from Ancient Times to Twentieth-Century America (New York: The Viking Press, 1952), pp. 229-30; Hough, “The Cowboy's Outfit.” 7. Rollins, “What the Cowboy Wore,” p. 108. 8 Gorshne, “The Cowboy,” p. 229 9 Rollins, “What the Cowboy Wore”; Gorsline, “The Cowboy”, Hough, “The Cowboy’s Outfit.” 10 Rollins, “What the Cowboy Wore,” p. 114 11. L. Wilson, “I Was a Pretty Proud Kid” (an interpretation of differences in posed and unposed photographs of Montana cowboys), Clothing and Textiles Research Journal 9, no. 13 (Spring 1991), p. 51. 12. Ibid., p. 57. 13. Fenin and Everson, “The Western Costume,” The Western. From Suents to. the Seventies (New York. Grossman Publishers, 1973), p. 109 14 J. Swallow-Reiter, “A Burst of Free Spints,” The Old West The Women (Alexandria, VA. Time-Life Books, 1978), p. 28.
Cowgirl Dress 69
J. Calder, “Women in the West,” There Must be a Lone Ranger (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1974), p. 158.
Ibid , p 157
Ibid., D. Gray, “Women on the Cattle Frontier,” Women of the West (Millbrae, CA’ Les Femmes, 1976), pp. 109-19.
Gray, “Women on the Cattle Frontier,” p 109.
Ibid.
Gray, “No Lite for a Lady,” Women of the West, p 109
D Russell, “A Dazzling Prelude to a Mighty Spectacle,” The Wild West (Fort Worth: Amon Carter Museum of Western Art, 1970), p. 2.
. Swallow-Reiter, “A Burst of Free Spirits,” p. 189
Russell, “A Dazzling Prelude,” p. 21.
E. Lawrence, Rodeo: An Anthropologist Looks at the Wild and the Tame (Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1982), p. 45.
C Eamer and T Jones, The Canadian Rodeo Book (Saskatoon: Western Producer Prairie Books, 1982), p. 9.
R Martin, “Cowgirl Country,” Cowboy. The Enduriig Myth of the Wild West (New York: Stewart, Tabor and Chang, 1983), pp 320-51.
Famer and Jones, The Canadian Rodeo Book, p 82.
Fenin and Everson, “The Western Costume,” p 190
Martin, “Cowgirl Country,” p. 335.
. S. O'Shea, “Cowgirl Cults,” Elle 6, no. 6 (September 1990) p 219
O'Shea, “Cowgirl Cults,” p 222. Ibid Fenin and Everson, “The Western Costume,” p. 190
. O'Shea, “Cowgirl Cults,” p. 222. . J. Tuska, “Women,” The American West in Film. Critical Approaches to the Western
(Westport: Greenwood Press, 1985), pp. 224-28.
. Martin, “Cowgirl Country,” p. 350.
. O'Shea, “Cowgirl Cults,” p 222.
. Ibid.
. M. Cahill, “Proving Everybody Wrong,” Debra Winger’ Hollywood's Wild Child (New
York St Martin's Press, 1984), p. 22.
. Ibid., p 23
. D. Shah and R Henkoff, “Nightclub Cowboys,” Newsweek 94 (9 July 1979), p 81 . Cahill, “Proving Everybody Wrong,” p. 23.
. O'Shea, “Cowgirl Cults,” p. 222.
. Eamer and Jones, The Canadian Rodeo Book, p 82.
. Ibid.
. Martin, “Cowgirl Country,” p. 329.
NANCI LANGFORD
“All That Glitters”
The Political Apprenticeship of Alberta Women, 1916-1930
Having secured the vote, we sat down satisfied without grasp- ing that the work had only begun. In other words, we had obtained the tools, but it remained to use them.... We, our- selves, were more or less dazzled when we secured the fran- chise; things seemed to be coming our way so easily. It has taken a few years for us to bite the coin and to learn once more, that all that glitters is not gold.!
One of the missing pieces in scholarly work on Alberta is an examina- tion of women’s political activism right after receiving the vote. Lim- ited analysis of the postsuffrage period characterizes it as one in which women activists retreated from political action, suggesting a decade or more of inactivity in both political lobbying and electoral politics. Compared to the success of the “votes for women” move- ment, which unified women’s organized reform activities and groups into a strong political caucus, the fifteen years following the passage of suffrage legislation were ones of confusion and adversity. Veronica Strong-Boag claims that feminism—particularly as an organized movement—was unable “to mount a sustained attack on male pre- rogatives in the public sphere after the suffrage campaign.”*
71
72. Nanci Langford
Legal reform campaigns of the early twentieth century, to secure prohibition legislation, dower laws, and female suffrage, were the first public political debates in which Alberta women participated with great energy and skill. These campaigns provided a focus for women to come together to influence electoral politics through effec- tive political lobbying activities. They can be seen as the beginning of Alberta women’s political apprenticeship. The period 1916-30 was a time of regrouping, experimentation, and coming to terms with new political realities, particularly the inability to meet many of the reform goals espoused during the suffrage campaign. Women’s new equality in electoral politics also brought a new diversity of goals and con- cerns to women’s political activities, both within and outside the political parties. More significantly, women learned that their new legal equality did not automatically bring inclusion, as equals, in political processes and organizations.
There is no doubt that Alberta women who had been active in securing the vote expected great changes to occur when women gained access to the ballot box. Despite the fact that many of these expectations were never met, Alberta women activists demonstrated a new sense of purpose and determination to use their new political rights effectively. They continued to organize to influence the political process; they launched an impressive education initiative to reach the new woman voter; and beginning almost immediately with the provincial election campaign of 1917, they participated in all facets of political campaigns in ways they never had before. In 1917 they elected the first women legislators ever to sit in any elected house in the British Empire. The immediate postsuffrage years, 1916-30, proved to be a difficult but productive period of political apprentice- ship for Alberta women.
Alberta Women Organize to Influence Electoral Politics
Some of Alberta’s prominent women responded immediately to the opportunity to work together as a coalition of people with common interests and concerns to use their new rights most effectively. In the week following the passage of the suffrage bill, a meeting was called at Nellie McClung’s Edmonton home, “for the purpose of considering the best method of forming a committee to consider the bills desirable for the women of the province of Alberta.”3
“All that Glitters” 73
The women who assembled at McClung’s home had a broader vision of their political role. They stated their goals in terms that reflected both their newly granted political equality, and their desire to move beyond gender politics to focus on society as a whole:
It shall be our aim and constant endeavour to make such use of these privileges as shall best forward and conserve the interests of the public as a whole, rather than those which pertain either to party or sex.4
At this historic meeting the women formed a Provincial Laws Com- mittee under the auspices of the provincial organization of the National Council of Women. Irene Parlby, a prominent spokeswoman for rural women, was unable to attend the meeting. Had she been present, one of the divisions that occurred between urban and rural women may have been prevented. Farm and country women viewed the local Councils of Women as urban based and often upper class organiza- tions, not representative of rural needs and interests. Although not intended to divide women into interest groups with different political agendas, the strategy to organize the Laws Committee under the coun- cil did exactly that. It was formulated in an environment of a growing class consciousness of farm women. Their new motivation for political action was stimulated by the franchise victory as well as the growing political influence and concerns of the United Farmers of Alberta.
Other new political organizations were formed in the decade fol- lowing enfranchisement. Despite the urging of many women to their sisters to retain “independence of thought” and nonpartisanship, the majority of these were party-allied organizations. Women who had worked together for common political goals now found themselves working against cach other by affiliating with political parties. In the process, the party agenda took precedence over women’s political reform goals. Women’s Liberal Clubs were established in both Edmonton and Calgary. Calgary women created the Women’s Labour League. Women’s sections were created within the Dominion Labour Party’s provincial organization and the Conservative Party. Nonparti- san groups were also formed for the purpose of political education and activity of their members. For example, branches of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom were formed in both urban centres in the decade following the first World War, as was the Calgary Women’s Political League.
74 Nanci Langford
The Political Education of Alberta Women
Some women activists were also acutely aware of the need to educate the new woman voter about her new responsibility as well as the issues of the day. In the years following the granting of suffrage, prominent women such as Emily Murphy, Cornelia Wood, Nellie McClung, and Irene Parlby, as well as journalists such as Francis Beynon, Miriam Allen de Ford, Eleanor Mack, and Margaret Donelly turned their attention to the political education of Alberta women. Speaking in 1916 to the opening of the Liberal Club in Edmonton South, Nellie McClung more clearly defined how women would use their votes, suggesting that they stay with the strategies and methods they had used as clubwomen and suffragists, influencing the political system from the outside:
The great field for the new woman voter is not that of practical pol- itics though nor does it concern the machinery of government. It is easy to get legislation when public sentiment is sufficiently strong, and it is in the education of public sentiment that the woman voter will be most in evidence I hope. ...1 can see that the great, inde- pendent unfettered body of women voters carefully studying the questions of human and social welfare, without bias, not looking for favours, or jobs, or preference, might become a factor in shap- ing the policies of governments, or in forming the platforms of oppositions.°
Miriam Allen de Ford appealed to young women voters in her col- umn in the Alberta Labour News, urging them to interest themselves in legislation that had their welfare in view, and “to use their brains when they vote.” Francis Marion Beynon offered this practical instruc- tion to women who read her page in the popular Grain Grower's Guide:
the first obligation of the new citizen is to refuse to be swept off her feet by any of the silly shibboleths of party politicians. Since there are no really independent newspapers she ought at election time to read at least two and try to assess as accurately as possible as to the truth concerning the questions up for discussion. This is the ABC of good citizenship.”
Not all women were enthusiastic about the franchise, but they nev- ertheless received a political education through local newspapers and
“All that Glitters” 75
their participation in a variety of women’s organizations. Emily Mur- phy, Nellie McClung, and Roberta MacAdams all addressed the Women’s Canadian Club in Edmonton in the early 1920s urging them to take an interest in laws being passed, to read newspapers, and to keep abreast of current affairs, so that they may use their franchise intelligently.8 Emily Murphy wrote an article for the Imperial Order of the Daughters of the Empire’s (IODE) 1916 Yearbook entitled “The Use of the Franchise.”? Reverend S.W. Fallis, in an address to the women at the annual meeting of the Calgary Young Women’s Christ- ian Association (YWCA) warned women against the dangers of party politics, and urged women “to make a study of conditions for them- selves that they might vote as intelligent citizens.”!° Speaking to the newly formed Calgary Women’s Political League in October 1921, Irene Parlby, newly elected member of the United Farmers of Alberta (UFA) government, suggested that “If we can give up looking at poli- tics through the prejudiced eyes of old party politics, then you will have no trouble in getting women interested in the formation of a good government.” 1!
Both the Alberta Women’s Institutes and the Local Councils of Women set up active committees within their organizations to study and recommend legislation to address the social reforms needed, par- ticularly those dealing with the concerns of women and children. One organization that appeared most earnest about the political education of its members was the United Farm Women of Alberta (UFWA). The success of organized women in urban centres in influencing the politi- cal system did not go unnoticed by farm women. Irene Parlby, in her report as president, spoke in 1916 to the UFWA:
The passing of the Equal Franchise Bill, early in this year, along with other things, showed the necessity of mobilizing the forces of farm women. The women in towns were well organized in differ- ent societies, and keeping a keen and watchful eye on passing events and legislation. It is also just and right that farm women should also be organized as a class, that they may have the oppor- tunity of expressing their views in regard to the legislation which may vitally affect their interests; also that by their united effort they may take their share in the building up of this new country. !
The UFWA not only encouraged women to develop knowledge and skills for participation in public affairs, they also gave their members opportunities to do so. The UFWA, through their locals and their
76 Nanci Langford
annual conventions, disseminated knowledge of public institutions and services, provided training in parliamentary procedure and the conduct of meetings, and helped women to develop public speaking skills. In her president's report at the 1919 annual convention, Irene Parlby defined the organization’s mission. “That most of us need a great deal of education along political lines is undoubted, and as we are likely to have both a provincial and federal election on our hands within the next year or two, this should probably be our chief line of work for the immediate future.”!3 The political education focus of farm women was partly motivated by the political aspirations of the United Farmers of Alberta. By 1919 the UFA decided to enter electoral politics with a farmers’ policy platform, both federally and in Alberta. The report of the Committee on Legislative Investigation, delivered by Mrs. O.S. Welch to the annual convention in 1920, reveals the expectations farm women held for themselves as political participants:
A great many women have declared themselves thoroughly dis- gusted with politics or not interested in politics and no time to bother with it. They are still thinking of politics in the worst old- time sense, bargaining politics. But they must have a cleaner and a higher meaning to us. We must realize what we can do in politics and begin at the right end. Politics should be met at our doorstep, in our own yard. ... We must realize our individual responsibility and accept that responsibility. We must thoroughly understand every question that comes before us, and with this understanding only, can we give our assistance in improving conditions. With the right of franchise it is our duty to use our vote intelligently at every opportunity.!4
The UFWA did not retreat from their political education program when the United Farmers of Alberta formed the government in 1921. S.E. Kiser, Chair of the Legislative Investigation Committee in that year, identified a “concern to build up a class of intelligent and enlightened workers from our own ranks and when a change in pre- sent laws or a new law is needed, we would feel satisfied that as an organization we were making no mistake in asking for same.”1°
The concern for the political education of the new woman voter generated an astonishing demonstration of interest and rhetoric by women across the province. Punctuated by idealism and good inten- tions, these new understandings would prove difficult to apply in the
“All that Glitters” 77
established system of party politics and government bureaucracy dominated by powerful men.
Alberta Women Enter Political Campaigns
With the calling of the 1917 provincial election in Alberta, women seized the opportunity to participate in political meetings and cam- paigns as they never had before. Rallies and all candidates forums at which women were the majority of the audience were common. Women often spoke on behalf of candidates, as well as about issues and the women’s vote. At a Conservative meeting in Edmonton dur- ing the 1917 campaign, Mrs. Macdonald declared “that women were anxious for the franchise . .. because it was hoped that women’s influ- ence would help to bring about better and more humane legislation, and that it would mean greater, cleaner and more economic adminis- tration.” 16
Cornelia Wood, speaking on the platform on behalf of a Liberal candidate, wound up a passionate plea to women voters with this statement:
Or shall we by the right of our common womanhood wake suffi- ciently from our indolence as to public affairs to say that our influ- ence is going to be used at the polls to right many wrongs, to better many conditions, to give justice and ambition for one’s country before personal greed and power.!7
And Nellie McClung, who claimed nonpartisanship by speaking for all “good” candidates, but advocated a return of the Liberal party because of their record of legislation that improved women’s status, made an appeal to women voters at a Liberal candidate’s meeting in Calgary. The Calgary Herald reported: “Mrs McClung said she would not be disappointed in the spirit of helpfulness, good fellowship and orderliness which the women would bring into political life.”18 One of the real ironies of this period of political apprenticeship is that often women who were, by personal example, pioneering new politi- cal roles and new attitudes towards women’s place in party politics were also those individuals, like Nellie McClung and Cornelia Wood, who asked women to remain impartial and fair-minded, and not fall prey to party politics. McClung’s support of the Liberals while asking
78 Nanc: Langford
women to be nonpartisan did not go unnoticed. She was singled out for criticism, but she was not the only woman who advocated this precarious political stance. During the 1917 campaign, Alberta news- papers published letters from women who wondered how they were to carry out the contradictory message of “remaining independent” and at the same time being asked to support a particular party.
Nellie McClung was one of the most prominent female participants on political stages in the 1917 provincial campaign. She was also elected to the legislature, along with Irene Parlby, former president of the UFWA, in the 1921 campaign. The active role played by women in the 1917 election was of great concern to some women who believed that this activity was not in keeping with the ideal of womanhood. Eleanor Mack, writing in her columns in the Calgary Herald, was most critical:
Party politics is a condition of affairs which the women have abhorred for many years. It is little wonder that everyone is amazed to find a few of the prominent women of the province sticking their fingers in the political pie for the present election....Let the women stand afar off on the hills of independence and keep cool until the political fray has passed.!9
The most apparent result of the first postsuffrage election cam- paign was the election of Louise McKinney and Roberta McAdams to the provincial legislature. Newspaper stories about the election noted the importance of this milestone to women in other countries. Its sig- nificance as a beacon of change of women’s position in society was recognized by suffrage campaigners throughout the British Empire. For Alberta women, who had petitioned for suffrage since 1905 and played significant roles in building new communities throughout the province, the election of women to the legislature was an endorse- ment of their demonstrated abilities in public affairs. In some respects, the successful candidacies of McKinney and McAdams were predictable developments, given Alberta society’s emerging attitudes toward women.
More telling, however, are the reasons for which both women won their electoral campaigns. Roberta McAdams seems at first an unlikely political candidate, and certainly seeking a seat in the legisla- ture was not her idea. Her candidacy and campaign were engineered by another Alberta woman, Beatrice Naismith, who was employed at the time by the Alberta government in its London, England, office.
“All that Ghitters” 79
McAdams was stationed in England as a nursing sister, with the rank of lieutenant, and eligible to be elected to the legislature as one of the two representatives of Albertans serving overseas in the First World War. She typified the “New Woman” of the period: single, indepen- dent, and accomplished. In 1915 she left her career as a teacher of home economics in Edmonton to serve in the war effort as a hospital dietician. Her campaign platform was two-fold: to represent the fami- lies of war veterans and returning soldiers, for whom she felt she could speak; and to represent the “other voice,” the voice of women in politics. The campaign slogan, created by Naismith, was “after you have voted for the man of your choice, give your other vote to the sis- ter.” Naismith’s understanding of gender politics paid off, but equally important was the recognition by soldiers and other nurses that McAdams was a capable individual because of the abilities and sense of duty she had demonstrated in her war work.
If McAdams symbolized what was new about women and their place in society, the success of Louise McKinney’s candidacy can be seen as symbolizing what was expected of a mature woman entering politics in 1917: she ran as an “independent” for the Non-Partisan League; she was a long time campaigner for suffrage, prohibition, and property rights for married women; and she was a living example of gracious Christian womanhood. In short, she was as an individual a true expression of the values and ideas of her time. She particularly represented the mood of the area in which she lived. Southern Alberta was the breeding ground for a new approach to politics, as farmers and ranchers there, many with American roots, were disaffected by the tactics and policies of the Liberal and Conservative parties. Both their experiences with other political alternatives and ideas in the United States, such as agrarian radicalism and the Non-Partisan League, and, in some cases, their lack of loyalty to Canadian political traditions, contributed to this region’s political atmosphere. McKin- ney believed strongly, as did many suffragists, that in bringing their own point of view to the legislature, women would have a reforming influence on society and on politics. She was widely viewed as a per- son who stood for a set of principles at a time when the population was hungry for a more principled approach to politics.
The demands for women’s political “purifying” role as well as for their abstention from partisan political activity were not just rhetoric of the suffrage campaign, but a reflection of society’s views about women, their attributes, and their roles. It was a view slow to change, as appeals to women on election campaign platforms throughout the
80 = Nanci Langford
1920s in Alberta demonstrate. Not all Alberta women then “seemed to stand more squarely on their feet than in the pedestal days” and “to have a new sense of responsibility of opportunities,” as Mrs. FF. McWilliams reported to the annual meeting of the National Council of Women of Canada in 1917.29 But the belief about the impact of women’s votes on the political system and the social order persisted, partly because it was supported by real evidence of women’s increas- ing involvement in federal and provincial election campaigns. As Marion Sears, president of the UFWA, declared after the campaigns of 1921:
I was wonderfully pleased with the intense and active interest that our women took everywhere in our provincial and federal cam- paigns. They showed a desire to cast an intelligent vote. ... with the majority of women taking part, the type of candidate we often have will disappear, and in future our representatives will be cho- sen for their greater integrity, honesty and morality, as well as their ability. Women’s house-cleaning propensities are going to be car- ried out in public life.2!
The Political Apprenticeship of Alberta Women
Several features of the postsuffrage campaign period, 1916-30, are striking. One is the degree to which the old ways of influencing politi- cal decision-making were still viewed as the most appropriate. For Alberta women, this meant trying to maintain a united bloc vote as women, organizing it through their clubs and organizations, bringing pressure to bear on both government and opposition parties to achieve specific goals. The enduring belief in this strategy is found in the continued appeals to women to join together to influence the political system. Mrs. Sears (UFWA) urged city and country women to unite their strength on common ground:
The aim of women’s organizations of today should be to strengthen their forces so that they will have an influence on the legislation of the country. ... Now that the women are enfranchised let them get busy and do what they can to make that enfranchisement of real value and something that will be of real service to our country and the good of humanity.?2
“All that Glitters” 81
Another reality was that women’s clubs and organizations were not representative of the majority of Alberta women. Despite unprecedented growth in both the number and membership of women’s organizations, they were still largely composed of well edu- cated middle- and upper-class women. And although there was sig- nificant cross-fertilization and cooperation among many groups, the organizations were still characterized by class and special interest dif- ferences. Most difficult to overcome were the tensions between urban and farm women, based on the fundamental differences in their lifestyles. The ability to unite to win causes such as suffrage and pro- hibition obscured temporarily the divisions and differences within the women’s community. New issues would make these divisions more apparent.
Women who chose to educate themselves politically by joining the traditional political parties were seen by some as betraying the inter- ests of women and succumbing to the evils of corrupt party politics. There seemed to be a greater tolerance for women’s involvement in the Non-Partisan League and the Labour Party, as both presented “nonpartisan” philosophies, despite their identification with class interests. Louise McKinney’s election to the legislature in 1917 as a Non-Partisan member, for example, was seen as consistent with her personal “good” values and her public roles in temperance and suf- frage campaigns. Roberta McAdams’s candidacy appealed to the armed forces voters on the grounds that she was an “independent,” that she was one of them, and she represented a special constituency rather than an established political party.
The idea of political neutrality was in direct conflict with other political realities. The party system, dominated by men, was alive and healthy in Alberta. Despite the significant role played by the Non-Par- tisan League in Alberta politics at the time, the choice for voters in 1917 was in most cases restricted to two parties: the Liberals and the Conservatives. The parties and the men who organized and repre- sented them were essentially the same as they were before women achieved suffrage. Women’s influence as voters was, with few excep- tions, limited by the necessity to choose between two alternatives which some women found equally unacceptable. The entry of the United Farmers of Alberta into federal politics in 1919 and provincial politics in 1921 offered a fresh provincewide alternative. Built on the success of its forerunner, the Non-Partisan League, which elected two members from southern Alberta to the legislature in 1917, the UFA was an alternative that appeared to many to be politically indepen-
82. = Nanci Langford
dent. However, “nonpartisan” tended to mean “not Conservative or Liberal.” Both the Non-Partisan League and the United Farmers of Alberta had definite platforms that favoured the farmer and sup- ported a number of contentious issues such as the nationalization of banking and credit systems, abolition of the Canadian Senate and a compulsory national insurance scheme covering accident, illness, old age, and death. Non-Partisan candidates and UFA candidates did pre- sent themselves as “Independents,” a label which had significant appeal to voters disenchanted with the established parties, which were identified with big business Eastern Canadian interests. Political “independence” came to be interpreted as freedom from both Eastern influence and from corrupt political practices. In the absence of voter statistics we can only speculate to what extent the votes of women who believed in political “independence” may have been responsible for the overwhelming success of the UFA in being elected to form its group government in 1921.
Despite the significant changes that had occurred in women’s lives and outlooks as a result of their involvement in the prohibition and suffrage campaigns, in women’s organizations, and in the war effort, the Victorian ideal of womanhood persisted. Women were already public persons, taking on new social and professional roles even before the Equal Suffrage Bill granted them equal political status with men. Francis Marion Beynon suggested that the standards expected of women voters, to be knowledgeable, pure, independent, and fair, were standards that many men had never been able to meet. In ques- tion was women’s “special” role in politics. The Victorian notion of women’s moral superiority and accompanying social responsibilities would gradually erode, as would women’s belief in men’s superior knowledge about political life.
For conscientious women activists, who fought long and hard for the right to participate as equals in the political system, the postsuf- frage years were a painful period of transition. They had to confront the realities of a confused, uninformed, and often indifferent female electorate, the potency of the male dominated party structures, and the gradual realization that the old ways of organizing and lobbying might no longer be possible or effective. Nellie McClung recognized the difficulties of this transition during the 1921 provincial election campaign:
The game of politics is new to women. We know what we want, but this method of achieving it is not so simple, nor so clear to us.
“All that Glitters” = 83
We are endeavouring to find the way. There are two ways before us:—One is to take things as we find them—and try to make them better, working with the tools already here, improving them as we can, never losing sight of the ideal, but using every means, imper- fect though they may be. The other is to stand aloof from the real business of life, and cry out for what we want, howling and protesting against every evil, but refusing to take part in politics until everything has become ideal.?3
Despite women’s past political successes in organizing for prohibition and suffrage campaigns, the mystique of male politics remained intact. As Irene Parlby discovered in her campaign for political office in 1921, old prejudices about women’s abilities survived. It was a dif- ficult, personal campaign, with her opponents declaring that as she was a woman and inexperienced in politics, she was unfit to legislate.24
Even in this political climate, significant gains were made in women’s access to political office and in their ability to influence leg- islators. Cornelia Wood, campaigning for the Liberals in 1926, assessed women’s progress this way:
During the past nine years since equal franchise was granted, women have not been idle and much progress has been made. The study of political events and the entrance of women into Public Offices from Alderman, School Trustee up to M.P. has made a great many women capable of marking an intelligent ballot as the major- ity of men are capable of doing.?
Several writers of the period commented that the Alberta experi- ence with the new female electorate was less of a failure than that experienced in other provinces. In her critical review article “Is Women’s Suffrage a Fizzle?” Anne Anderson Perry wrote in 1928: “In Alberta... much social legislation has been definitely furthered because of the urge of the women’s vote.”26 Alberta women’s new political activism was not as evident as some would have liked or anticipated it to be. In a biting article aimed at women voters in the 1930 election, Margaret Donelly commented:
In the present election campaign the ladies are conspicuous by their absence. It seems that the securing of the vote did not give women the proper place in society, and we are forgetting that the
84 Nanci Langford
vote was not an end in itself, but only a means to an end, namely the bringing about of a new type of legislation. ... Well, when the women want a bill, we turn it over to the men and they fix it up for men!27
It is significant that women of this period did not measure the suc- cess of their political activities by how many women held office at each level of government. They recognized from experience that polit- ical influence could be organized and exerted in a variety of ways, and the success of their committees and clubs in political education, lobbying, and effecting real political change in Alberta should not be underestimated. As a result, after gaining the vote, Alberta women did not restrict themselves to the traditional party system. Perhaps this reflects women’s orientation to politics as a means to accomplish specific goals, rather than as an end in itself. The potency of the disap- pointing lessons learned by women in party politics immediately after the vote was won may also be responsible. Women found them- selves outsiders in the mainstream parties, not welcomed as equals, and relegated to performing secondary roles.
The new awareness women gained of the real limitations of any advance in formal equality is a bitter but significant accomplishment of Alberta women’s political apprenticeship. Recognition that legal reform is a gain, but a limited one, full of contradictions which remain to be addressed, was a powerful and important lesson for women to learn. The wiser, more reflective and analytical viewpoints expressed in the late 1920s and into the 1930s by women prominent in the suf- frage campaign reflect these difficult lessons. Mary Ellen Smith described it aptly in 1928: “so far we women have been pretty well chloroformed in politics but we ought now to refuse all anaesthet- ics.”28 And in 1936, Nellie McClung admitted, “I blush when I think of all the things we were going to do when we got the vote.”29 Despite the fact that they did not meet the idealistic expectations of the suffrage promoters, women of Alberta did not fail in their asser- tion of their new political rights. The political education and appren- ticeship of Alberta women, however painful and disillusioning, was a tangible and significant outcome of the fourteen years following the achievement of female suffrage in Alberta.
Nanci Langford is a doctoral candidate in the Department of Sociology at the University of Alberta. Her research interests include the experiences of homesteading women on the prairies, the hfe and work of Louise McKinney, and theoretical approaches to analyses based on gender She is currently writing a book on organized farm women in Alberta, entitled Politics, Pitchforks and Pickle Jars
“All that Glitters” = 85
The author gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council in preparing this article.
Notes
1.
2
28.
29
CoM kw
Helen Gregory MacGill, “Are Women Wanted 1n Public Life?” Chatelaine (Septem- ber 1928), p. 50.
Veronica Strong-Boag, “Ever a Crusader’: Nellie McClung, First Wave Feminist,” Rethinking Canada. The Promise of Women’s History (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1986), p. 188
Edmonton Journal, 19 March 1916.
Ibid.
Edmonton Journal, 31 March 1916.
Minam Allen de Ford, “When a Girl Is Young,” Alberta Labour News (Edmonton: 18 September 1920).
. Francis Marion Beynon, “Wanted: A Sense of Responsibility,” Grain Growers Guide
(Winnipeg. 23 April 1917).
. Elise Corbet, “Woman’s Canadian Club of Calgary,” Alberta History 25, no. 33, 1977. . Emily Murphy Papers, City of Edmonton Archives.
. Calgary Daily Herald, 22 May 1917.
. Alberta Labour News (Edmonton: 5 October 1921)
Irene Parlby, “Report of the President,” UFA Annual Report, 1916, p 23 Irene Parlby, “Report of the President,” UFA Annual Report, 1919, p 81.
. O.S. Welch, UFA Annual Report 1920, p. 109.
. SE Kiser, UFA Annual Report 1921, p 97.
. Edmonton Journal, 29 May 1917
. Campaign speech on behalf of Frank Oliver, 1917 Provincial Election Campaign,
Cornelia Wood's papers, Provincial Archives of Alberta.
. Calgary Daly Herald, 4 June 1917. . Eleanor Mack, “A Word to Women Voters,” Calgary Daily Herald, 23 May 1917. . National Council of Women of Canada: The Year Book 1917-1918 (Toronto. National
Council of Women of Canada, 1918), p. 13.
. Manion L. Sears, “The Place of Women in Public Life,” UFA Annual Report 1921,
p.111.
. Alberta Labour News (Edmonton: 11 June 1921)
Alberta Labour News (Edmonton: 4 June 1921). Una MacLean, “The Honourable Irene Parlby,” Alberta Historical Remew 7, no. 4 (1959).
. Campaign speech, 1926, Cornelia Wood papers, Provincial Archives of Alberta.
Anne Anderson Perry, “Is Woman’s Suffrage a Fizzle?” Maclean's (1 February 1928), pp. 59, 63.
Margaret Donelly,”What’s the Matter with the Ladies?” Alberta Labour News (Edmonton: 14 June 1930).
Anne Anderson Perry, “Women Begin to Speak Their Minds,” Chatelaine (Septem- ber 1928), p. 50.
Globe and Mail, 13 November 1937.
LINDA TRIMBLE
A Few Good Women Female Legislators in Alberta, 1972-1991
Do women make a difference in political office beyond fostering the democratic principle of self-governance? Studies have found that the sexual division of labour shapes women’s values, perspectives, and patterns of social and political interaction.! Differences in life experi- ence may also be manifested in the attitudes and rhetoric of political elites;2 research conducted in the United States, Norway, and Canada indicates that female legislators are more likely to support the women’s movement than their male counterparts and tend to have different policy preferences. Yet in all three countries female legisla- tors are at times unwilling or unable to translate these preferences into action because their choices are inhibited by ideological and insti- tutional factors such as party positions on gender equality goals, sup- port for (or antipathy toward) women in the institutional environ- ment, and the mechanics of the legislative process itself.
This article briefly reviews the relevant literature on the impact of women in legislative office. I argue that while female politicians in the United States have a certain amount of legislative freedom, their female counterparts in other countries often do not. In particular, institutional factors such as party discipline and parliamentary proce- dure act as significant impediments to women’s representation in the Canadian case, as is illustrated by the province of Alberta. The state- ments and actions of female elected representatives in the Alberta
87
88 Linda Tnmble
Legislative Assembly between 1972 and 1991 illustrate that a “critical mass” of female legislators is a necessary but not sufficient prerequi- site for the development of a policy-making process which effectively takes gender into account and promotes the status of women. In the Canadian parliamentary system, the institutional constraints and opportunities confronting legislative women can be as important as the attitudes and motivations these women bring to public office. On the other hand, the Alberta case shows that “a few good women” can begin to challenge long-standing institutional norms, values, and practices.
Making a Difference?
Legislative women who support the goals of feminism can voice, and act on, these principles in three (overlapping) ways. First, they can articulate women’s lived experience, by, for example, drawing atten- tion to problems or concerns traditionally considered women’s respon- sibility because of the sexual division of labour, such as child care and care of the elderly, or by raising examples of the double discrimination faced by disabled, visible minority, native, or lesbian women. Second, female legislators can take gender into account when commenting on legislation, from labour policy to fiscal and tax policy. The impact of policy choices on women and men can be analyzed at all stages of pol- icy formation and legislative debate. Third, women in political office can demand or formulate public policies which will ameliorate sex- based discrimination and promote the social and economic status of women.
Studies of women in legislative office in the United States and western European countries conducted in the 1970s found that women elected to political office tended not to make a difference beyond advancing the democratic principle of representation.> While female legislators were inclined to be sympathetic to feminism and the goals of the women’s movement, women in political office seemed reluctant to act on these principles.4 Such findings led sociolo- gists and political scientists to introduce the concept of the “critical mass.”° Rosabeth Moss Kanter discovered that when small numbers of women entered male-dominated fields they were treated as tokens; this finding led political scientists to conclude that women must com- prise a significant proportion of legislators to be effective at the elite level.6 Bystydzienski, based on the Norwegian experience, argues that
A Few Good Women 89
“when female representation reaches at least fifteen percent it begins to make a difference.””
The “critical mass” hypothesis has been supported by recent stud- ies in the United States and in Scandinavian countries. In legislatures where women comprise more than ten to fifteen percent of the total legislators they tend to stimulate discussion of issues related to the socioeconomic status of women; identify women’s issues as legisla- tive priorities; propose more legislation in women’s interest areas than their male counterparts; and argue in support of feminist princi- ples and objectives.’ But a critical mass of women, even one which includes those committed to the goals of the women’s movement, is not in and of itself a sufficient condition for feminist dialogue in leg- islative institutions. Skjeie’s work on female legislators in Norway illustrates that gender differences in attitudes and preferences do not always manifest themselves in voting and other forms of parliamen- tary conduct.’ As Skjeie states:
While most women politicians want to make a difference, they do not want to act too differently. They use power strategies that cre- ate limited issue-specific alliances. But they avoid confrontations with male colleagues. Many seek to influence party viewpoints, but most do not challenge party priorities. ...It is indeed difficult to maintain difference among peers.}9
In other words, female politicians may sympathize with and support the women’s movement. They are less likely to speak for women in the formal institutions of political power. And acting for women is quite another matter.
This conclusion is borne out in the Canadian case. In Canada, female delegates to party leadership conventions tend to be more sympathetic to feminism and its goals than male delegates.!! But par- tisanship strongly affects the attitudes and behaviour of female politi- cal elites. For instance, Tremblay’s survey of candidates for the 1988 provincial election in Québec found party affiliation to be as impor- tant as gender in shaping attitudes about the women’s movement and the representative role of women.!% Party was a better predictor of approval for the women’s movement among Québec candidates, for instance.!3
Even if female partisans support the women’s movement, this is no guarantee that they will articulate, or act on, such views. For this rea- son we must ask what female legislators actually say and do in their
90 Linda Trimble
legislative roles. Do they raise different issues from their male coun- terparts? Do they discuss generic issues in a woman-sensitive man- ner? There is little Canadian research which examines the actions and statements of women in the legislative arena, although the existing evidence supports the argument that female politicians tend to speak on behalf of women’s equality. For example, Manon Tremblay found many female politicians in Québec express egalitarian and feminist ideas in their speeches before the National Assembly.'4
Do female politicians also act for women? Tremblay and Boivin’s study of House of Commons debates on abortion in July 1988 discov- ered female MPs were more likely to take a feminist position (pro- choice) than their male counterparts, but the gender differences were attenuated by party affiliation.!° Parliamentarians in this case were allowed to speak and vote according to conscience rather than accord- ing to the party line. But free votes are few and far between in Cana- dian legislatures, and there are infrequent opportunities for legislators to act outside the purview of party discipline. Carroll reports that female legislators in the United States have the following strategies at their disposal: voting, developing legislation, influencing colleagues, and building coalitions.!© Parliamentary behaviour in Canada is structured by parties and thus the approaches outlined by Carroll are unavailable to individual legislators. As well, because of the structure of parliamentary government, the opportunities open to governing party women will differ from those open to opposition party women.
In the parliament and legislatures of Canada, power is concentrated in the political executive—the prime minister or premier and his or her cabinet. In theory, the executive branch is responsible to the elected representatives of the people and must resign en masse if defeated on an important bill or on a motion of nonconfidence.!” In practice, if the governing party enjoys a majority in the House or Assembly it has vir- tual carte blanche when it comes to introducing policy initiatives, and can easily resist attempts by the opposition parties to amend or block legislation. Because every motion is treated as a confidence matter, tight party discipline is exercised. The practice of voting along party lines is rarely violated, thus encouraging a highly organized and scripted contest between governing and opposition parties which is dominated by the party in power.!8 Party whips, in consultation with party leaders, determine who is allowed to speak during debates and Question Period, and assign committee roles and other parliamentary tasks. MPs and MLAs, therefore, do not act as “free agents” and the ability of political representatives to raise women’s concerns is there-
A Few Good Women 91
fore largely determined by the willingness of the party to encourage this kind of discourse. If a party is unsympathetic to feminist demands its female members will have little recourse.!9
What women say and do in the legislature will depend on where they sit. Women elected to serve with the governing party may be chosen as cabinet ministers, in which case they will have the opportu- nity to develop gender equality policies and influence their cabinet colleagues. Once policy decisions are reached in cabinet, the principle of cabinet solidarity holds; all cabinet ministers (indeed, all party members) must support the policy in public and in the legislature. Backbench women (members of the governing party who are not appointed to cabinet) can raise gender-related issues in caucus meet- ings but must toe the party line in the legislature by speaking on behalf of, and voting for, government bills and motions.
Party discipline is not quite as confining for opposition members because their parties are not defending specific policy programs; the task of the opposition is to criticize the government's policies. As a result opposition parties tend to exhibit more in-fighting and may even air fundamental differences of opinion. Opposition party women have more freedom to articulate feminist positions, as opposi- tion parties generally eschew tight party platforms in favour of flexi- ble responses to government actions. Opposition women can use debates and daily Question Period to attack the government on its program for women or to criticize legislation which is insensitive to gender differences. Daily Question Period is the most effective forum, but it is only forty-five minutes long; the lack of sufficient time for opposition to present its views means that many issues are either overlooked altogether or are not discussed thoroughly.29 Opposition members can also introduce private member’s bills, though these rarely if ever come to a vote. In sum, while opposition women have little chance to directly influence policy, they have more institutional “room,” if their party is sympathetic, to raise gender equality issues in the legislature.
Legislative women of all partisan stripes can make a difference by redefining the role of the legislator. In other words, they may have an impact on process as well as on rhetoric. Rhetoric, or speech, refers to the content of legislative discourse. Process refers to the style of politi- cal action, the manner in which issues are raised and discussed, and conflicts settled. Since one of the goals of feminism is to challenge patriarchal structures and processes, the impact of women on the style of legislative debate is of vital importance.
92 Linda Trimble
Methodology
To determine whether a critical mass of women can make a difference within the parliamentary system, and to assess the extent to which factors such as institutional norms, party discipline, and legislative procedure provide opportunities or barriers, the Alberta legislative debates between 1972 and 1991 regarding women, gender equality issues, and policy issues of particular concern to women were exam- ined. Both the quantity of legislative debates on status of women issues and the nature and direction of the debates were analyzed. Alberta Hansard entries on women and gender equality issues were tabulated from 1972 (the year Hansard was introduced) to 1991. Each reference by an MLA to an issue such as abortion, day care, mid- wifery, or immigrant women, was counted as one entry. (See Appen- dix for a full list of topics.) The data were analyzed by gender, party, and role in the party. As well, the debates themselves were read to determine whether or not the female MLAs employed a different analysis of women’s issues and gender equality issues, and whether or not they adopted a different style of legislative debate.
The role and impact of women in the Alberta legislature between 1972 and 1991 are examined for two reasons. First, this time period spans years of low representation of women (less than five percent) as well as more recent sessions in which between twelve and sixteen percent of the MLAs were women (see Table 1). An analysis of womer’s legislative role over these two decades indicates whether the entry of significant numbers of women into elected office can change legislative debate. Secondly, the Alberta case study isolates two other important variables; party and role in the legislature. The Alberta leg- islature was dominated by one political party, the Progressive Conser- vative party (PCs or Tories), between 1971 and 1986. Opposition members only comprised eight percent of the MLAs in 1975, and the numbers dropped slightly as a result of the elections in 1979 (six per- cent) and 1982 (five percent). During this time period, all female legis- lators were members of the governing party, all refused to identify with the feminist movement, and few were in cabinet.
A new cohort of women was elected in 1986 and reelected in 1989. This contemporary group was dominated by government members but was distinguished by the introduction of several opposition women. After the 1986 election there were four opposition women and six governing party women; the 1989 election brought five oppo- sition and eight governing party women into the legislature. The 1986 and 1989 elections also yielded sizable (for Alberta) legislative oppo-
A Few Good Women 93
Table 1 Women MLAs in Alberta, 1917-89
ELECTION YLAR TOTAL SFATS SLATS WON BY WOMEN Ye WOMEN MLAs 1917 58 2 3.4% 1921 61 2 3.3% 1926 61 1 1.6% 1930 63 1 1.6% 1935 63 2 3.2% 1940 57 1 1.7% 1944 57 3 5.3% 1948 57 2 3.5% 1952 60 2 3.3% 1955 61 2 3.2% 1959 65 4 6.2% 1963 63 2 3.2% 1967 65 1 1.5% 197] 75 2 2.6% 1975 75 2 2.6% 1979 79 6 7.6% 1982 79 6 7.6% 1986 83 10 12.0% 1989 83 13 15.7%
Complied from Michael Palamarek, Alberta Women i Politics: A History of Women and Politics in Alberta (Report for Senator Martha Brelish, December 1989), Appendix C, and Report of the Chief Electoral Officer on Alberta Elections 1905-1982.
sitions; twenty-two opposition members in 1986 (26.5%) and twenty- four in 1989 (29%). Several of the new female MLAs are self-identified feminists and these women